McMahon #1 all day.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Mar 22, 2019
4:17:37pm

UNHuskerCoug Contributor

McMahon #1 all day.

Report problem with this ad

UNHuskerCoug

Previous username: UNHuskerCoug311
Bio page: UNHuskerCoug
Joined: Feb 10, 2018
Last login: Dec 7, 2019
Total posts: 1,704 (14 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Top 10 BYU QB’s ranked by overall career including NFL from 70’s on

CaliCougars

3/22/19 12:17pm

Beck should be higher.

3/22/19 12:19pm

Max Hall should be higher.

smokymountainrain

3/22/19 12:21pm

Also Max Hall should be higher.

JohnnyComeLately

3/22/19 12:21pm

Man.... there was a day in the early 90s I was positive I’d be on that list....

Pretorian

3/22/19 12:24pm

Taysom hasn't beaten out Max Hall yet

TPcoug

3/22/19 12:24pm

Again, Max Hall should be higher.

Fallball

3/22/19 12:25pm

People....we do not need a higher Max Hall.

byubyu

3/22/19 12:33pm

Laugh and Thumbs down at the same time.

TPcoug

3/22/19 12:36pm

RE: Top 10 BYU QB’s ranked by overall career including NFL from 70’s

occougar

3/22/19 12:34pm

Sarkisian just above Scheide. Carter belongs in The top ten.

Florwood

3/22/19 1:03pm

Agreed

8theU

3/22/19 1:22pm

Carter was pre 70’s

Cougzilla

3/22/19 2:13pm

BYU career only list would be quite a bit different

cougarnw

3/22/19 1:05pm

As far a NFL Marc Wilson should be #3 no question

8theU

3/22/19 1:17pm

He was the starting QB for a number of games during the Raiders 83 Championship

Dynasty1

3/22/19 1:33pm

I felt Detmer and Boscos accomplishments in collage made up for their NFL career

CaliCougars

3/22/19 3:00pm

TFD ok but put almost any of these QB’s on the 84 team

8theU

3/22/19 3:07pm

<< Deleted >>

3/22/19 1:51pm

Sark didn't bowl as a Jr. What about John Walsh and Brandon Doman. Both played

Coogar2

3/22/19 2:17pm

It was actually a very hard list to make I left off some QBs that I love

CaliCougars

3/22/19 2:58pm

McMahon #1 all day.

UNHuskerCoug

3/22/19 4:17pm

Not if you count NFL career. Young is top 10 all time QB

Dynasty1

3/22/19 4:19pm

McMahon was pretty good in the NFL. not as gojd as Young.

UNHuskerCoug

3/22/19 4:29pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad