Reese’s Pieces

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 21, 2019
1:34:24pm

HeismanTy All-American

Reese’s Pieces

Report problem with this ad

HeismanTy

Bio page: HeismanTy
Joined: Apr 17, 2010
Last login: Jan 1, 2024
Total posts: 6,554 (160 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Best non-chocolate candy of all-time

Odysseus

4/21/19 1:06pm

Airheads.

RalphWiggam

4/21/19 1:09pm

Watermelon Sour Patch Kids

kccougar

4/21/19 1:09pm

Swedish fish

Champ Kind

4/21/19 1:10pm

Gross, but good call due to popularity

Odysseus

4/21/19 1:33pm

Loved the pixie sticks! Always the most interesting for me to eat.

BlueFever

4/21/19 1:16pm

Pop Rocks too. Loved those.

BlueFever

4/21/19 1:18pm

Good n Plenty

mightybrick

4/21/19 1:18pm

That is disgusting . . .

TBabyCougs

4/21/19 1:27pm

Tangy taffy - with laffy taffy a close second

Spocougar

4/21/19 1:19pm

Hi chews and sour patch kids get an honorable mention

Spocougar

4/21/19 1:20pm

Gummy bears/ Cinnamon bears

pegushin

4/21/19 1:21pm

Pulparindo

Jeffacka

4/21/19 1:22pm

Hi chews

DrKennethNoisewater

4/21/19 1:25pm

Red Vines

Lifi

4/21/19 1:26pm

Sour cherry balls

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

4/21/19 1:26pm

Maybe not the best, but Mamba are very underrated imo.

cougaman

4/21/19 1:26pm

Raspberry Mambas and grape Hi-Chews are co-champions.

Loon to the Moon

4/21/19 2:14pm

Hi-Chews

StrongBad

4/21/19 1:30pm

Hi chew by far.

zephyr

4/21/19 1:30pm

Sugar Babies

Faceman

4/21/19 1:33pm

Reese’s Pieces

HeismanTy

4/21/19 1:34pm

They have a chocolate shell though.

cougaman

4/21/19 2:02pm

No they don't

Faceman

4/21/19 2:18pm

Then this gets my vote.

cougaman

4/21/19 2:29pm

But they should. Peanut butter m&ms are way better

supertux

4/21/19 3:21pm

agreed Pb M&M's are the best. But for best non-chocolate...Pieces has it.

HeismanTy

4/21/19 4:22pm

Payday

Tuss

4/21/19 1:37pm

Pecan Molasses candy. Only available in Hurricane, Utah by the old timers

HighHorse

4/21/19 1:38pm

Or pralines from New Orleans

HighHorse

4/21/19 1:42pm

Gummy bears etc

Baron

4/21/19 1:45pm

Sweet Tarts.

777

4/21/19 2:02pm

Love me Rips and any derivation thereof.

Adwight

4/21/19 2:02pm

Bit o honey, Mary Jane , Cow dots, PeanuButter bars/Chicostix, Boston BakedBean

4/21/19 2:03pm

Boston Baked Beans, for sure. I STILL enjoy those.

BlueFever

4/22/19 12:04pm

Hi chews, peach rings.

conetah

4/21/19 2:22pm

Mamba are pretty good.

4/21/19 2:34pm

As are Hi-Chew. Starbursts are awful in comparison to either.

ataylor

4/21/19 2:46pm

Sugar Babies then Bit o honey

fulano

4/21/19 2:36pm

I’d have loved trading Halloween candy with you.

ataylor

4/21/19 2:47pm

Bottlecaps

TheHop

4/21/19 2:54pm

<< Deleted >>

Breaded Hamster

4/21/19 3:07pm

Sunkist Fruit Gems

BYUtka

4/21/19 3:45pm

Vote for Nerds ropes.

soupie

4/21/19 4:20pm

Chewy spree. Or now and later. Or the old big chewy sweet tarts.

panguitch

4/21/19 10:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad