Not a valid argument. USU and BSU could regularly beat a reasonable amount of P5 teams...

Report problem with this ad

May 14, 2019
1:58:53pm

Refugee Starter

Says nothing about P5 vs G5 vs independence.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on May 14, 2019 at 1:58:53pm

Message modified by Refugee on May 14, 2019 at 1:59:15pm

Report problem with this ad

Refugee

Previous username: SoutheastIdaCoug
Bio page: Refugee
Joined: Sep 6, 2016
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 7,086 (113 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Jason Buck crying out for attention again:

Richbyu

5/14/19 11:50am

Brad Rock. Ugh.

YSMACK

5/14/19 11:52am

Such a lazy sports writer. Always writing negative articles on BYU. Haven't

Dangerous

5/14/19 12:09pm

Yep. Good take or not, we all know where Jason stands on independence....

Hawk in the 303

5/14/19 12:36pm

"The Rockmonster"

LDTemplar

5/14/19 1:15pm

Rock writes this same article every year

RenoCoug

5/15/19 10:22am

Has he asked for his retired jersey to be removed too?

BYUtka

5/14/19 11:52am

Buck speaks the truth on this topic!

What_The_Hill?

5/15/19 12:12pm

On having a retired jersey removed?

BYUtka

5/15/19 12:22pm

Indy is ripping my heart out too. Sucks having the season over after the first 4 games

DKN

5/14/19 11:52am

RE: Indy is ripping my heart out too. Sucks having the season over after the first 4 games

Indy Coug

5/14/19 11:54am

I can’t quit you

DKN

5/14/19 11:55am

I hate Indy. Would love to be part of the American for BBall and Football.

Klompus

5/14/19 12:21pm

Ditto

CheeseburgerEddie

5/14/19 3:58pm

He's my least-favorite past BYU player ever. He does more to hurt the program now than he ever did to help it.

MaxxPower

5/14/19 12:57pm

I think independence has done more to hurt the program than anything else.

DKN

5/14/19 1:12pm

What has he done to hurt the program?

Go_Trojans

5/14/19 4:56pm

It wasn’t last year

puntersarepeople

5/14/19 3:22pm

At least we have 5-6 good games now before the season is over

BallisLife

5/15/19 9:26am

If he is going to do it, better now than during the season.

BYU71

5/14/19 11:53am

Why is this considered crying out for attention?

Baron

5/14/19 11:53am

Because in reality richbyu is crying out for clicks

DKN

5/14/19 11:54am

What do "clicks" get me? Can I use them to buy a sandwich?

Richbyu

5/14/19 11:55am

Lots of folks love attention

DKN

5/14/19 11:55am

Meh....I wish I could buy a sandwich.

Richbyu

5/14/19 11:57am

What kind of sandwich do you want? Turkey Bacon Avocado from Zubs sounds good.

BYUtka

5/14/19 12:30pm

Something from the BYU creamery.

Richbyu

5/14/19 12:38pm

Fries and Ice Cream too while you are there?

BYUtka

5/14/19 12:39pm

I feel like he does this every year. Buck is always complaining about something

ReggaeCoug

5/15/19 10:11am

If current state football isn’t ripping your heart out something is wrong.

Mr. Scoobs

5/14/19 11:54am

<< Deleted >>

East1999

5/14/19 11:56am

Amen. We don't need backward steps.

fulano

5/14/19 11:57am

Boise state and Utah state you consider behind us?

USMCdad

5/14/19 11:58am

USU, yes. They've had 2 good years. And avg 20,000 fans per game.

Richbyu

5/14/19 12:01pm

Regarding potential of where they could go long term. yes.

fulano

5/14/19 12:04pm

I guess I just feel until we regularly beat MWC rivals we aren’t above them

USMCdad

5/14/19 12:46pm

Not a valid argument. USU and BSU could regularly beat a reasonable amount of P5 teams...

Refugee

5/14/19 1:58pm

Exactly, and for those teams they can regularly beat it would look silly for

USMCdad

5/14/19 6:28pm

Yet they are still G5 and therefore relegated. Nothing in the foreseeable future will change that.

Refugee

5/15/19 7:22am

Yup

rggee

5/14/19 12:05pm

The MWC is looking down the barrel of not having a TV Contract

Richbyu

5/14/19 11:59am

Yep - do these writers not look at our future schedules. The next three years

Dangerous

5/14/19 12:07pm

Meh. I’d rather go 10-2 or 9-3 every year in G5 than 6-7 or 7-5 every year.

Traveshamockery

5/14/19 5:39pm

Yeah but THIS year we are gonna be good. Lol

Gerald-DeGroot

5/14/19 12:10pm

After awhile, a former player's opinion means just as much as anyone else's

Indy Coug

5/14/19 11:54am

It must be hard for former players to see where we are at when compared to when

USMCdad

5/14/19 11:55am

Well said.

Richbyu

5/14/19 11:58am

I agree. But when you look at some BYU legacy kids that have gone to Utah,

crack

5/14/19 12:09pm

Absolutely. So why would any former player in their right mind advocate

LiveCoug

5/14/19 12:11pm

Whoa seems a bit dramatic. It's super disappointing being damned to 4 to 8 win seasons forever but not heart-ripping

TEXAS

5/14/19 12:00pm

Brad Rock and Doug Robinson write these articles every couple months. Things

Dangerous

5/14/19 12:05pm

Don't bring that rationale and fact pattern to this emotional argument!

BlackBart

5/14/19 1:52pm

Something you need to understand

shakarocks

5/14/19 3:24pm

One of the main reasons BYU left the MWC was because they weren't on tv

mwcoug

5/14/19 5:35pm

Anybody that says to follow Utah State gets a thumbs down in my book

mudpupper

5/14/19 12:08pm

85-44

LuvMyAggies

5/14/19 2:04pm

Was that the score of last year's BYU vs USU basketball game?

Richbyu

5/14/19 2:30pm

The REAL problem is the majority of the legacy guys from the hay day would

kotacoug

5/14/19 12:12pm

Hard to argue - look at the way some of them

truecougster

5/14/19 3:03pm

Question: how do you know Jason Buck was a great player

Str8CashCougar

5/14/19 5:22pm

Jason Buck loves attention. Plus he cheers for Utah

cougforever

5/14/19 6:34pm

Brad Rock is a hard core Yewt fan with an agenda to dig at BYU every chance he

Rocketman

5/15/19 5:31am

I can't remember the last time Rock wrote about BYU that wasn't a snarky,

BRATS

5/15/19 5:56pm

Former BYU football players sure complain and cry a lot.

dodgersjazzcougs

5/15/19 11:45am

If we can’t get in a P5, I’d rather go back to the MWC.

BOOHOLE

5/15/19 12:54pm

Jason Buck loves himself some Jason Buck...

aaronmania

5/15/19 2:50pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad