We often compare players at different positions and offensive vs defensive matchups but what about comparing coaching staffs. Realizing we all have a bias towards our teams coaches let's try to play an impartial game of who would you rather have?

Whitt vs Sitake - I would take Whitt not sure a good argument for Sitake

Ludwig vs Grimes - This one is tough for me, I really like how Grimes ran your offense last year and got a lot out of the players. Ludwig has more experience but hasn't really killed it anywhere since the 08 season and even then there were times fans were pulling their hair out. I think I would go Grimes here especially considering it's year 2 vs year 1

Scalley vs Tuiaki - I go Scalley as it seems like he has really gotten into a groove calling plays. Utah held Washington to 1 FG on offense in the title game last year. He does struggle with running QBs but most defenses do. I liked Tuiaki as our D line coach but haven't been overly impressed with him as the coordinator.

Looking at positional coaches I think there is some back and forth. I'd take OL, DL, and DB coaches from Utah. LB from BYU. Not sure on QB coaches, I didnt really care for ARod at Ut in that role. I like Utahs RB coach but BYU's is also solid. BYU's OL coach might do good but being brand new hard to pick him. WRs coach I like Utah but I don't know enough about Fesi. 

Overall I give the edge to Ut based on Whitt and overall experience but how close do you guys think the staffs are?