If you're talking combo, then McMahon/Hamilton should be on the list. Waymon

Aug 20, 2019
11:21:07am

mrphotogenic All-American

Hamilton may not have been the most prolific runner in BYU history, but he was very serviceable and a very good pass catcher as well.

Report problem with this ad

mrphotogenic

Previous username: 84 Grad
Bio page: mrphotogenic
Joined: Oct 10, 2002
Last login: Jul 24, 2020
Total posts: 27,111 (368 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Who’s the best Quarterback/Runningback combo in BYU history?

Dynasty1

8/20/19 11:05am

Great poll....ugh!

Borg

8/20/19 11:08am

I honestly can't pick. There are valid arguments for any of those.

BYUtka

8/20/19 11:08am

there is definitely a no brainer though and the votes show that.

fulano

8/20/19 11:11am

The Combo that won a National Championship?

BYUtka

8/20/19 11:13am

QB/RB combo means more than just how good they were as individuals.

fulano

8/20/19 11:17am

Agreed: Staley was a great back, but Doman was nowhere near our best QB

(Private)

8/20/19 12:01pm

This is my second choice

LDTemplar

8/20/19 4:11pm

Talent? Taysom/Jamaal. Career together? Max/Harvey. Single season? Doman/Staley

mjmill

8/20/19 11:16am

^^This is the correct breakdown of possible answers.^^

Six Foot Seven

8/20/19 11:18am

Agreed. I'd love to have seen Taysom and Jamal with the O-Line that Detmer had!

AFewThoughts

8/20/19 11:27am

Just thinking the same thing. Thanks Bronco/Anae for GFGH lightweight Oline!!!

CObluezone

8/20/19 12:42pm

Remember watching Detmer have 5 - 10 seconds just sitting in the pocket? Wow!

AFewThoughts

8/20/19 1:04pm

what about good looks and man crushes?

Cougarclaw

8/20/19 11:27am

Taysom and Taysom

JohnnyComeLately

8/20/19 11:32am

RE: Taysom and Taysom

cruiserhead

8/20/19 11:33am

Skill? Beck/Brown.

CougarMandias

8/20/19 4:47pm

Taysom/Jamaal will always be in the "what could have been" box

Fdnman

8/20/19 11:17am

If Doman/Staley had a defense, that would have been the best team in BYU history

Six Foot Seven

8/20/19 11:17am

Who could stop Robbie Bosco and Lakei Heimuli?

BYUtka

8/20/19 11:22am

Steve Young and Steve Young

Clark Addison

8/20/19 11:19am

McMahon and ______

UCLACoug

8/20/19 11:20am

If you're talking combo, then McMahon/Hamilton should be on the list. Waymon

mrphotogenic

8/20/19 11:21am

Yeah there were a few more I was thinking about adding

Dynasty1

8/20/19 11:27am

Young and Lane would have been a great add. Two future NFL players. 1984 was

mrphotogenic

8/20/19 11:30am

Yeah but while Lane did play pro he wasn’t a huge producer at BYU

Dynasty1

8/20/19 11:31am

Lane was a pretty vital player. From the Deseret News:

mrphotogenic

8/20/19 11:40am

Zack Wilson and Ty'son Williams.

Cougarclaw

8/20/19 11:30am

🤞

Dynasty1

8/20/19 11:31am

So let it be written. So let it be done.

CoogsWin

8/20/19 11:54am

Best I would say Doman/Staley. My favorite: Taysom/JW

cruiserhead

8/20/19 11:32am

Should be Taysom and Jamaal

Ham

8/20/19 12:13pm

I was just going to say Taysom. He played both.

TailgateU

8/20/19 1:37pm

Who were the QBs with Todd Christensen and Matt Belini?

scott715

8/20/19 1:37pm

Beck/Brown in my opinion. If I was putting together a team and had to choose

(Private)

8/20/19 1:53pm

Valid, and I agree with your answer when you frame it that way.

CougarMandias

8/20/19 4:48pm

McMahon and Vai Sikahema if you count punt returns. They were awesome!

Posting on CougarBoard