Seems to me BYU plays more Texas type schools than Kansas type schools. I think the ranking would improve if BYU was

Report problem with this ad

Oct 8, 2019
1:06:27pm

MaxxPower Playmaker

In a P5 conference because BYU would get to play lower-end teams more often.

Report problem with this ad

MaxxPower

Previous username: FancyFeast
Bio page: MaxxPower
Joined: Mar 6, 2016
Last login: May 11, 2024
Total posts: 4,907 (441 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU vs P5s compared to other P5 schools vs P5s (since 2000)

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

10/8/19 11:11am

Not all P5 teams are created equal. Why do you pretend they are?

SandYFan

10/8/19 11:15am

Wut? It's not like BYU picks and chooses when their P5 opponents are at their peaks/low points.

mulletino

10/8/19 11:20am

Of course not. What's your point?

SandYFan

10/8/19 11:21am

That BYU is about the 45th best P5 program in the country. Seemed clear to me

Cougar76

10/8/19 11:22am

What is your point? Who says all P5s are created equal?

mulletino

10/8/19 11:26am

Going 10-0 against P5 teams vs going 0-10 against P5 teams can mean

SandYFan

10/8/19 11:30am

Like I said, BYU can't/doesn't pick and choose weak P5s to play. Really weak P5s won't even play BYU. So...

mulletino

10/8/19 11:34am

Looking at win/loss vs P5 and comparing makes no sense.

SandYFan

10/8/19 11:40am

BYU doesn't play weak slates of P5s. Never has, never will. 19 years seems like a good sample.

mulletino

10/8/19 11:41am

Are you arguing that over the course of 19 seasons the average P5 team has

gww687

10/8/19 1:17pm

For your reference

CommodoreCoug

10/8/19 11:22am

Seems to me BYU plays more Texas type schools than Kansas type schools. I think the ranking would improve if BYU was

MaxxPower

10/8/19 1:06pm

Pretty good, considering BYU did that with no P5 benefits

Reedme

10/8/19 12:49pm

RE: BYU vs P5s compared to other P5 schools vs P5s (since 2000)

mikealta27

10/8/19 12:52pm

So now 50% of games are at home and refs don't screw us? Sounds good

Cougar76

10/8/19 12:58pm

Better, because we would also be playing bad P5 teams instead of just the good

andrewg3

10/8/19 1:05pm

My thoughts exactly. We'd be playing a range of teams.

Benfica1

10/8/19 1:08pm

BYU would average a 5-7 or 4-8 season, depending on the conference

Indy Coug

10/8/19 1:18pm

Probably average 5-8 wins a season - they'll play good/bad teams H/H

Benfica1

10/8/19 1:20pm

<< Deleted >>

gww687

10/8/19 1:22pm

Also, most have been away form LES. Most p5s have H/H.

Benfica1

10/8/19 12:53pm

How many P5 teams are there? 60? I don’t think that stat is all that great?

Pretorian

10/8/19 2:51pm

65. I didn't say it was great.

Indy Coug

10/8/19 2:55pm

I do think BYU has definitely played more upper tier P5s than lower

Pretorian

10/8/19 8:45pm

It’s not, but we do it without any of the benefits of P5. If we were invited to

Cougar76

10/8/19 3:03pm

Money isn't the biggest issue. It's institutional.

Indy Coug

10/8/19 3:07pm

Recruiting as a P-5 member would get noticably better, though. That'll help.

BleedCougarBlue2

10/8/19 3:50pm

Scheduling of P5 games since 2000 — 26 (H), 37 (A), 12 (N)

wjman11

10/8/19 5:14pm

Yes, half the neutrals are in the other teams backyard.

Benfica1

10/8/19 8:57pm

Seems about right

Posting on CougarBoard