Right, which is why I question the coaching staff. They obviously made conscious

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 21, 2019
11:36:59am

cougaman All-American

Right, which is why I question the coaching staff. They obviously made conscious

decisions with Warner and Wilcox. Why not do the same early on with promising freshman at positions of weakness like Keanu Hill. He should RS, but why did he play in the 2 games before last week? BYU didn't have a commanding enough lead for him to get real reps in any other games.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 21, 2019 at 11:36:59am

Message modified by cougaman on Nov 21, 2019 at 11:45:50am

Report problem with this ad

cougaman

Bio page: cougaman
Joined: Mar 11, 2006
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 68,623 (4,435 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This is the kind of stuff that annoys me with this staff. Why are these players

cougaman

11/21/19 11:16am

So you were expecting these players to get a bunch of time vs SDSU and [bowl opponent]?

Indy Coug

11/21/19 11:18am

You never know whats going to happen with injuries and what they will need. I'm

cougaman

11/21/19 11:23am

And if those meaningful snaps help BYU win the games, that's still an overall

basman

11/21/19 11:27am

No, but the meaningless snaps early in the season are, like I stated in my OP.

cougaman

11/21/19 11:29am

In addition, I think it's more reasonable to expect a true freshman to get

cougaman

11/21/19 11:28am

Haven't redshirting players always been able to play in bowl games?

Kajdin

11/21/19 11:34am

You must not have been around for the Squally Canada fiasco...

cougaman

11/21/19 11:37am

Keanu Hill has only had a few snaps all season

BYU Fan

11/21/19 11:34am

Right, which is why I question the coaching staff. They obviously made conscious

cougaman

11/21/19 11:36am

Seems like Hill will play against UMASS and then not again.

JuicyJam

11/21/19 11:38am

I agree, I just think he could play meaningful snaps against SDSU or the bowl

cougaman

11/21/19 11:41am

It is interesting that he played in the Tennessee game.

JuicyJam

11/21/19 11:47am

What kind of snaps did he play in the Tenn game?

cougaman

11/21/19 11:50am

No idea. That’s just what it said in the article.

JuicyJam

11/21/19 12:40pm

I didn't expect you to know. More of an open ended question. It probably wasn't

cougaman

11/21/19 12:47pm

Don't forget the new rule where a player can play in up to 4 different games and preserve their redshirt.

Indy Coug

11/21/19 11:37am

As long as they stop at 4 and don't need them later

BYU Fan

11/21/19 11:44am

Does it matter? They aren’t high on the depth chart or they would be playing

Boring

11/21/19 1:09pm

Maybe not as freshman but we may wish they had another year in 2023

BYU Fan

11/21/19 1:16pm

By my comment I mean just redshirt them.

Boring

11/21/19 1:54pm

It does matter. It's small attention to detail that seperates the average from

cougaman

11/21/19 2:36pm

Hill is, and he would be playing if there are injuries

cougaman

11/21/19 2:22pm

Both Jackson Kaufusi and Wilgar redshirted? What are you smoking right now?

puntersarepeople

11/21/19 2:56pm

Last year they did. Jackson was shut down before the Utah gave last year.

cougaman

11/21/19 3:38pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad