My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 13, 2019
5:21
:57
pm
gwalker
All-American
I didn't realize it, but my list spaces things out nicely over several eras IMO.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
gwalker
Bio page
gwalker
Joined
Aug 8, 2001
Last login
May 4, 2024
Total posts
55,348 (7,385 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: I'm wondering if there's consensus on best player in BYU basketball history?
Gorgias
12/13/19 5:10pm
Rafa by a mile
DieHarder
12/13/19 5:11pm
While the others were very good players, if you had to choose a
gwalker
12/13/19 5:21pm
I didn't realize it, but my list spaces things out nicely over several eras IMO.
gwalker
12/13/19 5:21pm
Definitely Hutchins, he was a great NBA player and he lead the 1951 BYU team to
Dynasty1
12/13/19 5:26pm
It was the most prestigious at the time.
gwalker
12/13/19 5:27pm
Yeah, I’d basically count that as a National Championship team
Dynasty1
12/13/19 5:30pm
Definitely Hutchins. Smith would be the 5th.
Yohy
12/13/19 5:31pm
Mel Hutchins and Wilt Chamberlain are the only rookies in NBA history to lead
Gentleman Stan
12/13/19 5:44pm
He’s probably the most underrated BYU athlete ever considering his
Dynasty1
12/13/19 5:50pm
It would have been interesting if Krešimir Ćosić could have played in the NBA
CougarVeteran
12/13/19 7:03pm
Could have or would have?
SpiffCoug
12/13/19 7:10pm
Maybe a bit of both
CougarVeteran
12/13/19 8:35pm
He chose not to.
CougarThug
12/14/19 9:11am
He captained his team to an Olympic gold medal, so I'd say there's pretty
Gentleman Stan
12/13/19 7:11pm
He was offered a huge contract (for that era) by the Lakers
AZ Coug
12/13/19 8:01pm
One always has to ask: BYU only or incl post BYU career?
Yohy
12/13/19 5:30pm
Career as a BYU player
Gorgias
12/13/19 5:36pm
Then Jimmer. He put a team of decent, not great players on his back to sweet 16
Yohy
12/13/19 6:02pm
There were 2 other NBA guys on that team (Davies, Collinsworth) not to
Dynasty1
12/13/19 6:08pm
Davies would have been nice but as you recall, he did not
Yohy
12/13/19 6:15pm
Jimmers great. But if postseason is the primary measurement,
Gentleman Stan
12/13/19 7:09pm
Any of your top three listed.
SpiffCoug
12/13/19 6:16pm
If Bradley stuck around, he'd be near the top. What might of been.
mudpupper
12/13/19 6:38pm
Jimmer? how was his NBA career? How many champs did he win? FF, E8?
flyzag
12/13/19 7:19pm
RE: Jimmer? how was his NBA career? How many champs did he win? FF, E8?
BlueTroop
12/13/19 8:36pm
Ainge is the ONLY answer here.
flyzag
12/14/19 12:30pm
Austin,
BlueTroop
12/14/19 1:26pm
You left Tavernari off the list?
BlueTroop
12/13/19 8:34pm
Obviously no consensus.
rockyrd
12/13/19 8:48pm
As with many of these polls, would be interesting to see by age breakdown
D.T. Survivor
12/13/19 11:33pm
I was born in the late 80's but I'd probably put Jimmer 4th behind Ainge,
Dynasty1
12/13/19 11:38pm
Jimmer was the most exciting
Mabuhay Coug
12/14/19 12:49am
Give ainge three point shots and a shot clock
CoogsWin
12/14/19 8:40am
you forgot to add Nick Emery
pappabear246
12/14/19 9:22am
RE: you forgot to add Nick Emery
BlueTroop
12/14/19 1:27pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
