The only criteria that everyone added was reality. Plus, if you write a poll in

Jan 29, 2020
11:20:37am

cougarfan84 All-American

such a way that "everyone else" is applying criteria that you don't want them to apply, it's probably a poorly written poll.

Report problem with this ad

cougarfan84

Bio page: cougarfan84
Joined: Apr 3, 2003
Last login: May 7, 2024
Total posts: 19,208 (2,484 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: If you had to pick one BYU being Ranked or BYU getting a playin game which would

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:03am

Ranked at season end

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:04am

Ranked at year end would only happen if we make the tourney

Coop

1/29/20 11:06am

Think that's the idea. If one happens, the other comes along too.

Soupie

1/29/20 11:07am

that's not necessarily true. USU was ranked at the end of year once and did not

BlueK

1/29/20 11:10am

Sixteen years ago

Coop

1/29/20 11:13am

SMU in 2014

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:14am

the human polls in basketball just don't matter, IMO

BlueK

1/29/20 11:15am

Very true

Coop

1/29/20 11:47am

Well....if BYU gets ranked at this point in the season, they'll likely be better

che flaco

1/29/20 11:05am

Exactly. Easy choice.

byuluvr

1/29/20 11:06am

Huh? So it’s not possible never happened?

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:08am

Has it happened? I'd be surprised, honestly.

rggee

1/29/20 11:10am

Twice I can recall

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:11am

That’s like saying would you rather be ranked or bowl-eligible in football.

BYUCLA

1/29/20 11:06am

I'm wondering if he means "ranked but not make the NCAA tourney" vs "making the

jreid191

1/29/20 11:09am

Not quite. They'll give any team with a pulse a bowl invite these days

Indy Coug

1/29/20 11:09am

That’s the point. So why would you not picked ranked if you are ranked you are

cougarfann888

1/29/20 11:11am

Most likely but there are exceptions and that was the question one or the other

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:16am

what does ranked even matter if you don't make the tournament?

BlueK

1/29/20 11:08am

Not to me

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:13am

You guys forget SMU and USU seasons- point being you’re

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:10am

They both had terrible SOS, BYU is in the top 25 in SOS. For what it's worth.

rggee

1/29/20 11:13am

Completely agree but that wasn’t my question. Too many here foolishly thought

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:15am

The OP is kinda dumb, though. BYU wouldn't be in that situation at all.

rggee

1/29/20 11:16am

Dumb? Why because you and everyone else applied extra criteria to the OP? That’s

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:19am

The only criteria that everyone added was reality. Plus, if you write a poll in

cougarfan84

1/29/20 11:20am

Sure- REREAD THE QUESTION. Where did I remotely mislead or imply this team?

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:22am

For me, it was in linking to a poll talking about BYU's chances of being ranked

cougarfan84

1/29/20 11:24am

But considering the only way that BYU ends up ranked at this point is if they

cougarfan84

1/29/20 11:19am

Yes on all accounts but again I didn’t ask or imply anything about this team. I

SouthernBlueBlood

1/29/20 11:21am

Given the context that you wanted people to consider, I would take my odds of

cougarfan84

1/29/20 11:23am

If there is one of those things, there is likely the other to go with it.

rockyrd

1/29/20 1:58pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad