Penny Anne had my best Reuben ever too. But hasn't been able to duplicate it.

Report problem with this ad

Mar 30, 2020
3:57:21pm

Eddie Intervention Needed

I've been back a couple of times and ordered a Reuben, and neither time was it as good as the first. Makes me sad.

Report problem with this ad

Eddie

Bio page: Eddie
Joined: Dec 12, 2002
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 43,979 (900 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

restaurant with the best Rueben sandwich you've ever eaten? For me:

hxmCougar2000

3/30/20 3:53pm

Big Daddy's Reuben pizza on Freedom in Provo if you want it done differently!

runnincoug

3/30/20 3:55pm

interesting. I'll have to wrap my head around that one first.

hxmCougar2000

3/30/20 3:56pm

Penny Anne had my best Reuben ever too. But hasn't been able to duplicate it.

Eddie

3/30/20 3:57pm

Kneaders

Jimo Dashen

3/30/20 4:00pm

Langers Deli

BlueFrog

3/30/20 4:00pm

Yes - the #19 is the best in LA. Canter's is ok in a pinch

mcan

3/30/20 4:34pm

Katz’s Deli in NYC, NY

Jeff Spicoli

3/30/20 4:00pm

If you've been there, this is the only answer.

slappy

3/30/20 4:05pm

Katz’s is the correct answer, best pastrami reuben in the world

therock

3/31/20 12:07am

Won’t be popular here but jersey mikes has a passable Reuben.

RalphWiggam

3/30/20 4:00pm

Arby's has a great Reuben

mrphotogenic

3/30/20 4:02pm

In Utah.... it's Feldman's Deli

HarlemCoug

3/30/20 4:02pm

Feldman's is amazing. My wife and I split one fairly regularly.

ebv

3/30/20 4:46pm

I’ll need to check it out. Thanks!

hxmCougar2000

3/30/20 11:14pm

Bagel Cafe in Las Vegas

DB Cooper

3/30/20 4:04pm

Smokey turkey Reuben, trade out kraut for slaw... come at me bro!

coug almighty

3/30/20 4:05pm

I think that is called a Rachel

SLC-Warrior

3/30/20 4:13pm

Well she didn't disappoint.

coug almighty

3/30/20 4:15pm

Rachel is made with pastrami but a lot of restaurants call it a Reuben. I always

mrphotogenic

3/30/20 4:21pm

I don't think I've ever had a bad Reuben anywhere

mwcoug

3/30/20 4:07pm

<< Deleted >>

Food Snob

3/30/20 4:08pm

Not Slymans in Cleveland. Supposed to be good, wasn't.

unctoothman

3/30/20 4:17pm

Paul’s Deli in Williamsburg, VA.

flavordave

3/30/20 4:19pm

Max's in Highland Park, IL.

sfeuz

3/30/20 4:31pm

Eisenbergs Deli in NYC. Right by the Flatiron building. In business since 1929.

Posting on CougarBoard