It's just not all or nothing for me. I'm happy to look at the strengths and weaknesses of each coaching staff.

Ultimately, you're right, it's about bringing in talent (i.e., how good the players were), so of course Bronco is going to get grief when he has one or more low talent walk-on starters. Kalani would, too, as they both should. Doesn't make someone a hater for pointing it out.

Also, can you point me in the direction of people that complained about playing Rich as a walk-on? He's one of BYU's best safeties of all time.