Herbie mentioned last night that other than BYU at #14, the next most surprising

Nov 25, 2020
6:44:28am

mwcoug All-American

ranking was Northwestern at #8. They should not be ranked that high. There must have been some committee members pushing hard for NW.

Report problem with this ad

mwcoug

New username: thewaterboy
Bio page: mwcoug
Joined: Apr 25, 2006
Last login: May 22, 2021
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

For those who are claiming BYU has been the victim of collusion or at least some

NorthwesternSeasider

11/24/20 11:56pm

Just means Coastal Carolina also need to farther up

Rat

11/24/20 11:59pm

I guess the eye rolls and laughing faces are proof that this is an unpopular

NorthwesternSeasider

11/25/20 12:00am

The way everything unfolded this week was a little too convenient

mobius

11/25/20 12:02am

Spend more than 2 minutes looking at their w-l record and the answer is obvious

11/25/20 12:04am

I’m not sure I follow.

NorthwesternSeasider

11/25/20 12:05am

Exactly

11/25/20 12:06am

You’re referring to CCs W-L record or another teams?

NorthwesternSeasider

11/25/20 12:08am

Look at any of the advanced analytics and they show a clear separation between 2

11/25/20 12:12am

RE: You’re referring to CCs W-L record or another teams?

ChandlerAZCoug

11/25/20 4:13am

RE: Spend more than 2 minutes looking at their w-l record and the answer is

ute15

11/25/20 2:18am

Look at how those games went smart guy. Bsus worst home loss in 25 years.

BYU '80

11/25/20 4:56am

3 places is a huge deal considering the implications and they know BYU only has

PortlandCoug

11/25/20 12:04am

That 3-spot difference basically knocked BYU out of a NY6 game.

swingcat

11/25/20 12:05am

I don’t disagree. It sucks. I just don’t think it’s a conspiracy.

NorthwesternSeasider

11/25/20 12:09am

Nobody will ever know. But the hypocrisy in how BYU was evaluated is what makes

whoneedscorners?

11/25/20 1:04am

I almost can buy into your reasoning, but then

hdx57

11/25/20 3:57am

And magically two Iowa teams, one undeserving of a ranking at all and Iowa St which is wildly overrated in the rankings

BYU '80

11/25/20 4:58am

RE: I guess the eye rolls and laughing faces are proof that this is an unpopular

ChandlerAZCoug

11/25/20 4:09am

There has never been a team drop six spots from both polls

BYU '80

11/25/20 4:55am

What's your explanation for the huge disparity between AP voters and CFP?

swingcat

11/25/20 12:02am

The burden of evidence is not on him. He’s not the one claiming there’s a conspiracy.

Dr MoBYU

11/25/20 12:06am

Not really a conspiracy when this Crap happens every year, we’re just the latest

akmewg

11/25/20 1:00am

It’s a fair question. I think we fail to remember that the original AP

NorthwesternSeasider

11/25/20 12:07am

In a normal season, yes. We would have played and beaten 5 or 6 P5 teams.

DMVCougar

11/25/20 12:33am

It’s not a normal season and if it was BYU would have already beaten several p5s

BYU '80

11/25/20 4:59am

0 of 64 AP voters had BYU 14 or higher. 0...with a Z

EtTuKalante

11/25/20 6:58am

I don't think it is a conspiracy. It's just poor rationale.

shimmy

11/25/20 12:04am

They have a beef too. College football needs an expanded playoff. Teams like

Countcougula

11/25/20 12:07am

Been saying for years the NCAA needs a 16-team playoff. Play a 10 game regular

BleedCougarBlue2

11/25/20 12:59am

RE: Been saying for years the NCAA needs a 16-team playoff. Play a 10 game

ChandlerAZCoug

11/25/20 4:18am

Sagarin has Penn State, 0-5, ranked #19. The computers aren't working in Covid

Cougar8Duck

11/25/20 12:10am

IMO, any undefeated G5 team should be ranked ahead of the whole Big12.

ldssdl

11/25/20 12:11am

Oh yeah, and not a single B12 team has fewer than 2 losses. What a joke.

ldssdl

11/25/20 12:16am

It’s not specific to BYU. The conspiracy is to keep everyone not in P5 out and maybe

Soupie

11/25/20 12:14am

They threw the G5 a bone to keep them happy

A Drew Aitch

11/25/20 12:15am

It's a house of cards driven by one thing & one thing only: money.

BleedCougarBlue2

11/25/20 1:00am

Seeing Oregon behind us makes me think that maybe it isn't a conspiracy.

ditch

11/25/20 12:18am

So 14 is the line, but 15 could’ve been a conspiracy?

Kugmo

11/25/20 12:27am

...but USC is still behind that, so not a conspiracy then?

Kugmo

11/25/20 12:29am

RE: ...but USC is still behind that, so not a conspiracy then?

Kugmo

11/25/20 12:36am

What has Oregon done. They haven’t even blown out bad teams

BYU '80

11/25/20 5:00am

They are behind BYU THIS week. NEXT week, they will pass BYU up.

byusage

11/25/20 5:43am

Us I am sorry but what part of a Northwestern Logo says Us?

LEDSFW

11/25/20 12:24am

Herbie mentioned last night that other than BYU at #14, the next most surprising

mwcoug

11/25/20 6:44am

CFP effectively swapped our spot with Northwestern

DMVCougar

11/25/20 6:54am

So, by that logic, it's a sign of disrespect that cinci is that high, right?

SUAVO

11/25/20 12:42am

Why would UW sources "leak" that BYU was holding out on negotiations. Lies.

Yiowa

11/25/20 12:43am

They haven't looked nearly as dominant. Not to slight the Chantacleers, though.

SinkingQuffa

11/25/20 3:11am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad