Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up
Nov 29, 2020
2:29:27pm
BYUDM93 Walk-on
What is your ranking philosophy?

There are many, maybe countless.  But, I found it interesting to look at two basic ones, and their combination.
Initial ground rule: I only worked with the current Week 14 AP Rankings list.  I didn't mess with who should or should not be in there at the bottom.

First, I looked at a pure RESULTS method with a simple sort.  The rules here are:
  1) A game played is of more value than a game not played.
  2) A win is worth 1 point
  3) A loss is worth -2 points
This is certainly most favorable to BYU, as it sits them at #2.


Second, I ventured a go at a PERCEIVED STRENGTH method.  By this I mean who I guess Vegas would pick as the winner in a head-to-head match-up at a neutral site with no fans - flat out, who they think is the better team in the match-up. Take 1v2 - who's favored?  Take 2v3 - who's favored?  etcetera.  I didn't go into any more complexity than that (but, but, but - A beat B, B beat C, but C beat A, so therefore...).  Just took a go at it.  I imagine there will be massive differences of opinion here.  I claim no experience or insight with betting, wagering, or anything of the sort.  It's just my best guess by impression.  It's obviously biased toward P5, 'cause that's reality.


Third, I just averaged the two ranks together for a COMBINED result.  Rather interesting, as it comes pretty darn close to the current AP poll, minus just a couple big anomalies (>= 5 diff from AP).
What are your thoughts?  Your rankings philosophy?





 RESULTS METHOD        PERCEIVED STRENGTH METHOD       COMBINED      
 AP RankRankTeamWLPtsAP Diff  AP RankRankTeamWLAP Diff  AP RankRankTeamWLAvgAP Diff
 21Notre Dame909+1  11Alabama800  11Alabama8010
 82BYU909+6  42Clemson81+2  22Notre Dame9020
 143Coastal Carolina909+11  23Notre Dame90-1  43Clemson815+1
 14Alabama808-3  34Ohio State40-1  34Ohio State408-1
 75Cincinnati808+2  55Texas A&M610  65Florida718+1
 156Marshall707+9  66Florida710  56Texas A&M619-1
 257Liberty917+18  117Georgia62+4  87BYU9010.5+1
 48Clemson816-4  128Iowa State72+4  98Miami7111+1
 209Louisiana816+11  139Oklahoma62+4  129Iowa State7211.5+3
 610Florida715-4  1610Northwestern51+6  1410Coastal Carolina9012+4
 911Miami715-2  911Miami71-2  711Cincinnati8012.5-4
 312Ohio State404-9  1812Wisconsin21+6  1612Northwestern5113+4
 513Texas A&M614-8  1913Oklahoma State62+6  1113Georgia6213.5-2
 1014Indiana513-4  1714USC30+3  1514Marshall7014+1
 1215Iowa State723-3  1015Indiana51-5  1015Indiana5114.5-5
 1616Northwestern5130  2316Washington30+7  1316Oklahoma6215-3
 1717USC3030  2117Oregon31+4  2517Liberty9115+8
 2218Tulsa513+4  2418Iowa42+6  1718USC3015.5-1
 2319Washington303+4  819BYU90-11  2019Louisiana8117+1
 1120Georgia622-9  720Cincinnati80-13  1920Oklahoma State6217.5-1
 1321Oklahoma622-8  1421Coastal Carolina90-7  2321Washington3017.5+2
 1922Oklahoma State622-3  1522Marshall70-7  1822Wisconsin2118-4
 2123Oregon311-2  2523Liberty91+2  2123Oregon3120-2
 1824Wisconsin210-6  2224Tulsa51-2  2224Tulsa5121-2
 2425Iowa420-1  2025Louisiana81-5  2425Iowa4221.5-1
                         



 



 


This message has been modified
Originally posted on Nov 29, 2020 at 2:29:27pm
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 29, 2020 at 2:34:48pm
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 29, 2020 at 2:35:17pm
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 29, 2020 at 2:36:09pm
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 9:55:35am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 9:59:01am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:06:39am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:07:34am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:08:27am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:10:28am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:13:08am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:23:10am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:39:53am
Message modified by BYUDM93 on Nov 30, 2020 at 10:40:31am
BYUDM93
Bio page
BYUDM93
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Last login
May 3, 2024
Total posts
446 (1 FO)
Messages
Author
Time

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.