Love the list. I’d either drop 2006 to tier 2 or upgrade 2009 to tier 1 as

Dec 1, 2020
11:22:03am

climps Redshirt Freshman

I think they’re pretty comparable seasons. Clobber P12 opponent in bowl game, dramatic win over Utah, two unfortunate losses for each.

Report problem with this ad

climps

Bio page: climps
Joined: Aug 12, 2013
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 353 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

In my book, there have been 7 great BYU football teams prior to this year

Doctor Rosenrosen

12/1/20 10:15am

I agree with your list. 2001's Defense kept them from being "great".

SlantRoute

12/1/20 10:16am

The Hawai'i loss keeps that team off the top list

Carnac

12/1/20 10:26am

Top Ten: 96, 84, 83, 79, 80, 06, 85, 81, 01, 07

arizonacougarfan

12/1/20 10:21am

'20 not on the list?

Cougz19

12/1/20 10:27am

Not yet. Depends how they finish the season

arizonacougarfan

12/1/20 10:27am

That's crazy talk. BYU's doing things that only a few teams have ever done.

cougfan03

12/1/20 10:41am

I think '09 might have been Bronco's best team.

Byron McNertney

12/1/20 1:10pm

I like your lists and can't fault your reasoning. At first I was thinking why you

IdahoCoug

12/1/20 10:29am

Gotta make a case for that 8-1 1932 team to be tier 2.

BlueVU

12/1/20 10:33am

I would argue that '09 needs to move up

Six Foot Seven

12/1/20 10:37am

Finishing undefeated puts 2020 in top tier, IMO

Y05

12/1/20 11:12am

Love the list. I’d either drop 2006 to tier 2 or upgrade 2009 to tier 1 as

climps

12/1/20 11:22am

2009 had 2 blowout losses and 06 losses were very very close.

arizonacougarfan

12/1/20 11:29am

True. I just value the win over Oklahoma more than anything from '06

climps

12/1/20 4:05pm

The bowl blowout of ranked OSU was also very memorable.

Y05

12/1/20 4:11pm

2009 could’ve been an all-time year but those losses... ugh.

Ned Schneebly

12/1/20 11:59am

I'd add 1981 and 2009 to the list of great teams.

The Chelsea Dagger

12/1/20 1:33pm

A loss to UTEP is worse than any blowout loss.

Blue Cat

12/1/20 3:35pm

Worst loss I can remember

Posting on CougarBoard