You have zero precedence for suggesting a G5 with more than even 3 P5s(let alone TWICE that), and goes undefeated, has ever been kept out of the NY6. My guess is no P5 has ever gone undefeated with more than 3 P5s.
I'm not sold that we would of made the CFP even with 6 or 7 P5s(like next yr), but NY6 most definitely