And do what, sort them alphabetically?

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 17, 2021
10:21:12pm

All-American All-American

And do what, sort them alphabetically?

A committee is a bad solution to a problem for which we have yet to come up with a better one.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 17, 2021 at 10:21:12pm

Message modified by All-American on Jun 17, 2021 at 10:22:24pm

Report problem with this ad

All-American

Previous username: all_american01
Bio page: All-American
Joined: Sep 5, 2001
Last login: Apr 30, 2024
Total posts: 14,955 (48 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If we are top 12 in indy we get an at large most years.

FieroCoug

6/17/21 9:57pm

If we are undefeated with a normal Indy sched, we are in, 1 loss we are out

BYUFootballisBack

6/17/21 10:00pm

Nope. We still get left out. They arent allowing two G5 teams in.

FieroCoug

6/17/21 10:04pm

When you're undefeated and get passed by a 3 loss iowa state you arent gonna get

FieroCoug

6/17/21 10:18pm

Agreed if we didn't learn from the Iowa State example we never will. An indy or

johnnybyu

6/17/21 10:20pm

Yup

ChinaFan

6/18/21 1:47am

You can't compare this last year's schedule to a normal Indy, undefeated BYU

BYUFootballisBack

6/18/21 9:20am

MAYBE as an undefeated. 1 loss and you're done. Thats where the AAC route is a

rggee

6/17/21 10:10pm

Plus front loaded road heavy schedules are not a recipe for a top 10 finish. I

johnnybyu

6/17/21 10:00pm

The schedule wouldnt be a ton different in the AAC. But a pretty weak late

FieroCoug

6/17/21 10:02pm

RE: The schedule wouldnt be a ton different in the AAC. But a pretty weak late

JDHouston

6/17/21 10:06pm

That seems reasonable

TNT

6/17/21 11:54pm

Just need to get rid of the committee, just way too subjective.

akmewg

6/17/21 10:18pm

This is the best answer.

FieroCoug

6/17/21 10:19pm

And do what, sort them alphabetically?

6/17/21 10:21pm

Computers already do this stuff without bias.

FieroCoug

6/17/21 10:33pm

No they don’t. They will show the bias of their programmers.

6/17/21 10:37pm

This kind of response is part of the problem. There are so many things that are

akmewg

6/17/21 10:38pm

Yeah, we went with the committee specifically because everyone hated computers

6/17/21 10:43pm

Nope, everyone hated a 2 team championship, the selection method got better and

akmewg

6/17/21 10:55pm

That is just not going to happen

Nat Gas Man

6/17/21 10:22pm

Hence the prob with Indy. Our first loss in Sept wipes out the postseason

Run-DMT

6/17/21 10:26pm

It isn’t just access, it is now certainly about the money as well

Nat Gas Man

6/17/21 10:35pm

Yep and playoff money is the best money and exposure.

FieroCoug

6/17/21 10:40pm

It isn’t more than media money for most p5 conferences, but it would be a huge i

Nat Gas Man

6/17/21 10:48pm

If there’s any committee selecting the remaining teams BYU is NEVER getting in

Coug Man in Florida

6/17/21 10:44pm

I suspect all the conferences will eject divisions. That leaves the top 2 teams

Nat Gas Man

6/17/21 11:17pm

the problem is the type of indy schedule you have to schedule and play to get top 12. Most of the time, it just isn't

ChinaFan

6/18/21 1:23am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad