They lost 4 games... 8-4 plus one win against Wyo in their bowl game.... so 9 wins, and 4 losses. 8 wins out of 12 tries is pretty mediocre especially when you consider who they beat. 3 P5 wins yes... but those three wins came against three teams that had 3, 3, and 6 win seasons respectively. Of the 7 regular season wins against D1 programs, your opponents had a total of 30 wins for an average record of 4 wins per team. Yep. Mediocre. Toledo is the only team with a winning record that BYU beat during the regular season. Again, that's a mediocre season if there ever was one.