Healthy Staley is a no brainer. When it comes to durability he doesn't score well against the others though.

Report problem with this ad

Jul 16, 2021
10:46:08am

Pimpin4Paradise Truly Addicted User

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jul 16, 2021 at 10:46:08am

Message modified by Pimpin4Paradise on Jul 16, 2021 at 10:46:58am

Report problem with this ad

Pimpin4Paradise

Previous username: ChubbyChaser
Bio page: Pimpin4Paradise
Joined: May 2, 2008
Last login: Nov 12, 2022
Total posts: 56,121 (5,737 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYUtv posted the easiest build your squad thing ever. There is really only debate about the second WR, right?

shimmy Shane Belieber

7/16/21 9:45am

There's an automatic choice for RB?

Indy Coug

7/16/21 9:45am

There should be but people will debate it. Collie, McMahon, and Pitta aren’t debatable.

shimmy

7/16/21 9:52am

QB is plenty debatable.

FieroCoug

7/16/21 10:55am

RE: QB is plenty debatable.

shimmy

7/16/21 11:21am

Healthy Staley is a no brainer. When it comes to durability he doesn't score well against the others though.

Pimpin4Paradise

7/16/21 10:46am

As a short-yardage back he wasn't that good either.

SinkingQuffa

7/16/21 1:26pm

The only one I see that's automatic is Collie

Kajdin

7/16/21 9:47am

Pitta and McMahon should be 100%

shimmy

7/16/21 9:51am

Google his butt

Solomon Levi

7/16/21 12:33pm

Instructions unclear, now I have IT and HR wanting to meet with me ASAP. Thanks.

joelvandyne

7/16/21 12:45pm

McMahon, Staley, Collie, Drage, and Pitt for me.

Marvelous

7/16/21 9:49am

This... although I might pick Unga – because it won't be an option system.

Benfica1

7/16/21 10:04am

Swap Drage for Bellini and we’re the same.

Ned Schneebly

7/16/21 1:21pm

4 of the 5 rows there's not really even a legitimate argument against the top choice.

OPINIONS

7/16/21 9:52am

You’ll get plenty of argument for QB

YIsForBrigham

7/16/21 9:56am

I think you could legitimately argue for each quarterback

D.T. Survivor

7/16/21 2:24pm

I'd take Young, healthy Staley, Collie, Drage, and Pitta

BYU Fan

7/16/21 9:54am

I think Drage would be the most popular 2nd wr, but I’d think about a deep threat to go with collie.

shimmy

7/16/21 9:56am

Who would you take as your deep threat?

BYU Fan

7/16/21 10:24am

Not listed, but I'd take Todd Watkins if the category is deep threat.

Thrill

7/16/21 10:37am

That one is hard for me because I see most of those guys are more possession types, even catching the ball downfield

shimmy

7/16/21 10:37am

They didn’t include prices so it’s not as fun

YIsForBrigham

7/16/21 9:56am

McMahon, Staley, Collie, Drage, Pitta

Jeffacka

7/16/21 9:59am

RE: McMahon, Staley, Collie, Drage, Pitta

Pimpin4Paradise

7/16/21 10:47am

I can pick any two of the eight WR, or do I have to pick one from each row?

hydrocoug

7/16/21 10:07am

I interpret it s 2 of 8. 1 from each line and its Collie and Drage 90% of the time.

shimmy

7/16/21 10:40am

Pitta was super prolific, but Jonny more formidable, & Smith more versatile

SinkingQuffa

7/16/21 10:35am

Wilson, Williams or unga, collie, milne, pitta.

FieroCoug

7/16/21 11:00am

It doesn't say one per line with the WRs, just pick two of the eight.

cambo

7/16/21 3:48pm

Watkins is my #2. Speed/Stretch the field

palangi

7/16/21 11:14am

On the days Watkins didn't suffer from the drops, he was excellent. Inconsistent

Forzaitalia

7/16/21 1:29pm

I could quibble with the order in a couple places but it's a pretty good list.

Forzaitalia

7/16/21 11:44am

Odd to anyone else to leave off Gordon Hudson entirely

stansburycoug

7/16/21 12:16pm

Not to mention Pili & Lewis. If the all-time greats are indeed represented there

SinkingQuffa

7/16/21 12:38pm

He’s also the only BYU TE in college football Hall of Fame

robin

7/16/21 1:37pm

Hard to imagine anyone who watched Staley play wouldn’t choose him

MDub1

7/16/21 1:04pm

Loved the power of Unga, the consistancy of Williams, but if I want a TD I hand

Mot

7/16/21 1:33pm

💯

MDub1

7/16/21 1:48pm

He’s the most explosive RB we’ve ever had. He, Taysom, and Young are some of the

pilot17

7/16/21 1:40pm

Great points all around.

MDub1

7/16/21 1:49pm

Young, Unga, Collie, Matthews, Pitta

Borg

7/16/21 1:12pm

Amazing how many aren't that high on Hoffman. He was ridiculous.

BlackBart

7/16/21 1:38pm

I watched all of them play (except for Bellini, but thanks to BYUTV

pilot17

7/16/21 1:45pm

Move him out of Collie's row and he'd be picked a lot more

Kajdin

7/16/21 2:32pm

It just says “Pick 2”, i.e., any two from all the WRs, not one from each row.

flyonawall

7/16/21 3:31pm

They failed to list BYU's best TE at all.

CMuehle

7/16/21 2:48pm

The only BYU TE in the college football Hall of Fame

Bill

7/16/21 5:47pm

Mathews was great, but I would not even consider him for a top 10 WR

Mot

7/16/21 3:30pm

Great athlete & size, but not very versatile at all.

SinkingQuffa

7/16/21 3:35pm

Its Collie and Hoffman. Anything otherwise is just flat out wrong.

cambo

7/16/21 3:40pm

I don’t know. Hoffman was a fumble machine

MDub1

7/17/21 12:01am

Huh? He had a career total of 5 fumbles (3 lost). Collie was 4 (2).

Byron McNertney

7/17/21 6:08am

Exactly! 50% more fumbles lost!

Clark Addison

7/17/21 12:10pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad