My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 21, 2021
7:50
:52
am
byubyu
Truly Addicted User
I don't know how what happened 35 years ago matters this season, but ok.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
byubyu
Bio page
byubyu
Joined
Jun 28, 2006
Last login
Apr 25, 2024
Total posts
65,863 (2,899 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Cincinnati deserves the Playoffs. Their only loss in 2 years is to UGA by 3 pts
Goliath
10/21/21 7:48am
I don't know how what happened 35 years ago matters this season, but ok.
byubyu
10/21/21 7:50am
You can pretend you can't see any correlation between the arguments people made
Goliath
10/21/21 7:55am
It's a very different landscape than it was in 1984.
ReyOso
10/21/21 8:01am
And yet the arguments for and against BYU back then are the same arguments today
Goliath
10/21/21 8:03am
Minus the playoff.
Q-grr
10/21/21 8:42am
RE: It's a very different landscape than it was in 1984.
akbarishiwatsu
10/21/21 10:32am
Well one problem is you're comparing a top 1 argument to a top 4 argument
byubyu
10/21/21 8:14am
Agree--if they win out, they should be rewarded for the past two years, just
Shinshin
10/21/21 7:51am
Yes if they win out they should go. But college football is mostly a sham so they probably won’t
YIsForBrigham
10/21/21 7:54am
I think they're in if they win out
displacedute
10/21/21 7:55am
Then you believe Gary Barta will fail at his main job.
zsmooth
10/21/21 8:05am
I think the first set of rankings will tell us if they’re serious about Cincy
Gator
10/21/21 7:55am
Their Sagarin SOS is ranked 93rd in the country. So they need Notre Dame to win out
TCuz
10/21/21 7:56am
I see the argument about their SOS, but this is pretty much the same team that
Shinshin
10/21/21 7:59am
So the next best part about their resume is that a team from a different year lost to another team.
TCuz
10/21/21 8:02am
I guess. If you ignore the part about how they performed against that schedule
Goliath
10/21/21 8:08am
How they performed against that schedule is reflected in their Sagarin ranking. They are #5. Behind Bama/UGA/OSU/OU.
TCuz
10/21/21 8:11am
So, that sounds pretty darn good.
Goliath
10/21/21 8:15am
That's why looking beyond simply "strength of schedule" and seeing how they
Goliath
10/21/21 8:00am
Looking at previous years also benefits Bama, UGA, OSU, OU. The exact teams ahead of them.
TCuz
10/21/21 8:09am
It should definitely be considered. Shouldn't be given priority over this years
Goliath
10/21/21 8:19am
They've been accepted in the cartel so the cartel may let them join the playoff
vagabonder
10/21/21 7:59am
They’re not gonna let the AAC have all that $$ this year just cause Cincy is moving to the cartel later.
zsmooth
10/21/21 8:06am
Ash tray money for the Cartel. NBD.
grosven
10/21/21 9:31am
Never happening
troutmaster13
10/21/21 8:04am
Their SOS is bad, very bad
2FarGone
10/21/21 8:05am
I want to see them in the playoff. I hope they win out
Adrielle
10/21/21 8:06am
No one who matters really cares who deserves to be in, that’s not their goal.
StalwartBraveTrue
10/21/21 8:12am
Weird that the G5 members of that committee are just good to go with the conspiracy!
TCuz
10/21/21 8:17am
Hair Thompson and the AD from Arkansas state? They’re supposed to have a
StalwartBraveTrue
10/21/21 8:23am
They deserve to be in the playoff simply to beat GA in 3OT in NC game #SECShorts
(Private)
10/21/21 8:36am
UCF had two years with ZERO losses going into the playoff selection
krindorr
10/21/21 8:41am
Nowhere did I hint that this was a prediction. I said it is what they deserve
Goliath
10/21/21 8:47am
We're in agreement there
krindorr
10/21/21 9:33am
thumbs up they deserve, thumbs down, don't trash 84!
Tuskaloosa Cougar
10/21/21 8:53am
I'm not trashing '84. Just pointing out that you can't trash Cincy without
Goliath
10/21/21 9:26am
oh im just having fun. I agree!
Tuskaloosa Cougar
10/21/21 9:38am
The biggest difference between 1984 and now isn't what you think
krindorr
10/21/21 10:52am
Hard to argue but shows how easy it is to play that schedule - still gotta
truecougster
10/21/21 10:37am
Cincy is good, but their QB has a shady look to him. Not a fan.
SJS
10/21/21 10:38am
their profile is definitely more deserving than 1984 BYU
Hill4Heisman
10/21/21 11:19am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
