Looks like you're the only one who has it right on this thread now 👍

Report problem with this ad

Dec 7, 2021
11:41:20pm

Machiavelli All-American

Report problem with this ad

Machiavelli

Previous username: Machiavelli127
New username: MaximusMeridius
Bio page: Machiavelli
Joined: Nov 10, 2015
Last login: Aug 8, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Offside? Really?? They’ll be talking about this call for years. (Link)

BluesBrother

12/6/21 9:42pm

She looked offsides to me from that angle

cougarblue

12/6/21 9:44pm

Freeze it when it was kicked.

BluesBrother

12/6/21 9:44pm

Honestly I take that back after looking at this pic

cougarblue

12/6/21 9:50pm

It really was a beautiful play

bluelands

12/6/21 9:58pm

Incredible finish.

Benfica1

12/6/21 9:59pm

Looked on to me.

YSMACK

12/6/21 9:49pm

Look at the shadows of the feet. She's on.

Benfica1

12/6/21 9:52pm

Definitely on.

unctoothman

12/6/21 9:52pm

When you freeze it on the moment of the pass, she is onsides

Goliath

12/6/21 9:45pm

Is the rule she needs to be onsides when the pass is made..if so, she's onsides

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

12/6/21 9:47pm

Yes

Littlerich

12/6/21 9:48pm

Yep.

BluesBrother

12/6/21 9:48pm

yup. that is the rule. it was the wrong call

cwilke1

12/6/21 9:49pm

Yes, offsides is based on where the recipient is when the pass is kicked, not where the recipient receives the ball

SingleStrapBackpack

12/6/21 9:49pm

Wow, I hadn't seen it until now. That doesn't even look level. That looks like the BYU player is slightly behind.

SingleStrapBackpack

12/6/21 9:50pm

Other angles I've seen can't be used. This is best one.

Soupie

12/6/21 9:52pm

That is a real shame

SingleStrapBackpack

12/6/21 9:57pm

And it clearly shows she is onsides

Unibro

12/6/21 10:05pm

its a shame. She looks clearly on. its so hard to decide it without

cwilke1

12/6/21 9:48pm

Pretty dumb a national championship can't have video review.

JuicyJam

12/6/21 9:57pm

Even the FSU defender doesn’t raise hand until she knows she can’t catch Tucker

NewMexiCoug

12/6/21 9:48pm

I’m pissed even though I have no idea what I was supposed to see.

bluecheese

12/6/21 9:51pm

That’s a goal

TempeCoug

12/6/21 9:56pm

Wow, between this, the no call second yellow on #6, and the stutter

Oompabluepaw

12/6/21 9:56pm

Stutter or feint was totally legal unfortunately.

blau56

12/6/21 10:22pm

What? You cannot pause. She did not stutter. She paused. Absolutely illegal.

jcase16byu

12/7/21 12:27am

And I totally agree with you. But that was the only way they could justify

blau56

12/7/21 8:55am

Foudy thought the only possibility was the shoulder was off

bluelands

12/6/21 9:59pm

My response to thatwith no lean that I can see the defender's foot is ahead

coug10278

12/6/21 10:05pm

That’s my read on it too. NCAA should have VAR for the College Cup.

The Chelsea Dagger

12/6/21 10:08pm

Absolutely onsides

Unibro

12/6/21 10:04pm

Anybody know if they were Pac12 refs…..?

byublue42

12/6/21 10:20pm

That person should never ref again. It's NOT a tough call.

yahoo1211

12/6/21 10:30pm

Only needed one.

Soupie

12/6/21 10:37pm

For the record its called "offside"..no S. More people get that wrong than right

Machiavelli

12/7/21 12:17am

Thanks. Fixed.

BluesBrother

12/7/21 6:24am

Looks like you're the only one who has it right on this thread now 👍

Machiavelli

12/7/21 11:41pm

We are in America. It's accepted use to say offsides

Goliath

12/8/21 3:07am

Lol and he uses Wikipedia to back it up

Machiavelli

12/8/21 11:20am

Gosh, you seem like such a sweet guy and a pleasure to discuss with

Goliath

12/8/21 11:34am

<< Deleted >>

Machiavelli

12/8/21 1:22pm

RE: Lol and he uses Wikipedia to back it up

Posting on CougarBoard