Broad appeal and excellent talent in that group. So many good songs.
But they might be just shy of all-time upper echelon of bands. Maybe not actually. But if they do fall short it would have to be due to the lack of any cult following. I don't see the crazy 'eagles are the best bad ever' people.
But imo they are among the best ever. Top. 10 probably. Oddly, I would out them there and still say there might be 10 or 12 other bands who I would listen to first.