Max Hall:
-Winningest QB in BYU history (32) (best year 11-2)
2007: 11-2, 2008: 10-3, 2009: 11-2
-Career stats: Yds 11,365, Comp % 65.3, TD 94, Int 40
-Record against Utah 2/3
-1 conference championship
-Undefeated in press conferences
NFL: UDFA

John Beck
-23 wins (best year 10-2)
2003: 2-6, 2004: 5-6, 2005: 6-6, 2006: 10-2
-Career Stats: Yds 11,021, Comp % 62.4
TD 79, Int 34
-Record against Utah 1-2
-1 Conference Championship
NFL: 2nd round draft pick

Zach Wilson
-20 wins (best year 11-1)
2018: 5-4, 2019: 4-5, 2020: 11-1
-Career Stats: Yds 7,652, Comp % 67.6, TD 56, Int 15
-Record against Utah 0-2
NFL: 1st round, 2nd overall pick

Both John and Zach had one magical season, but the rest of their careers were average. Max Hall easily had the best college career and is a top 5 BYU QB of all time IMO