Why? A player running after the whistle doesn't do anything. They don't get

Sep 24, 2022
11:00:09pm

Alpi Gusto All-American

the yardage, nobody gets hurt. There aren't any negative consequences if the offense keeps going. But if a defensive player tackles someone after the whistle, they're likely defenseless and could get hurt. Not really equal, IMO.

Report problem with this ad

Alpi Gusto

Previous username: (Private)
New username: RealTaysomHill
Bio page: Alpi Gusto
Joined: Feb 7, 2011
Last login: Oct 18, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If they’re gonna penalize defenders for tackling after the whistle they should

CougfromtheSouth

9/24/22 10:57pm

That’s a valid argument.

HingleMcCringleberry

9/24/22 10:58pm

Why? A player running after the whistle doesn't do anything. They don't get

Alpi Gusto

9/24/22 11:00pm

It’s not only running, it’s handing the ball off to another player

LonePeakCoug

9/24/22 11:02pm

I think it’s possible that the RB didn’t bear the whistle either.

HingleMcCringleberry

9/24/22 11:02pm

Then call it consistent. Penalize both teams for playing after the whistle.

here's to hoping

9/25/22 1:33am

When you play football, hearing is one of your weakest senses. Sight and touch

CougfromtheSouth

9/24/22 11:03pm

To all three of you, this is a response to the hypothetical "new" rule of

Alpi Gusto

9/24/22 11:04pm

Let me be annoyed in peace

LonePeakCoug

9/24/22 11:07pm

Oops, my bad. No, actually that was a great call by the ref and BYU should be

Alpi Gusto

9/24/22 11:13pm

Glad you are here to be the voice of reason

LonePeakCoug

9/24/22 11:19pm

Incentive to keep playing after the whistle to catch defense into continuing to

here's to hoping

9/25/22 1:38am

What about tackling guys if there are no whistles? *eye roll.*

andrewg3

9/25/22 12:22am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad