No. You are dead wrong in this case because you are cherry-picking one subset of

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 30, 2022
3:09:19pm

shoganai Intervention Needed

No. You are dead wrong in this case because you are cherry-picking one subset of

circumstantial data from one game to filter out and ignoring any other related circumstantial considerations in any of the others. For what you're doing to be relevant and accurate, you have to apply a consistent and balanced filter to the whole data set.

If you have the time or inclination to do so, I'm sure we'd all be interested in seeing it. But, only applying one element of it to one game is not statistically sound at all. It's just basic cherry-picking.

Report problem with this ad

shoganai

Bio page: shoganai
Joined: Jul 15, 2004
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 31,598 (790 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU opponents' YPP against BYU, and against everyone else...

shoganai

9/30/22 2:09pm

Good job

Blueto

9/30/22 2:13pm

Oregon took their foot off the gas against us. They were at 8.36 YPP ...

Coop

9/30/22 2:20pm

This is why we use averages.

shoganai

9/30/22 2:24pm

Your understanding of statistics is . . . incomplete. At best.

Coop

9/30/22 2:41pm

I'm not the one cherry-picking data to make a predetermined point.

shoganai

9/30/22 2:45pm

Wrong. Both in terms of what I am doing and what you are doing wrong.

Coop

9/30/22 3:02pm

Works both ways though. USF, Wyoming, and USU picked up yards when BYU took

Blueto

9/30/22 3:06pm

For sure.

Coop

9/30/22 3:17pm

No. You are dead wrong in this case because you are cherry-picking one subset of

shoganai

9/30/22 3:09pm

Just stop. You clearly don’t know what you are doing.

Coop

9/30/22 3:16pm

Interesting you would say that because you just agreed with my point when

shoganai

9/30/22 3:21pm

You didn't make that point at all. It is a valid point, and I would have ...

Coop

9/30/22 3:28pm

I'm sorry if you felt I was being uncivil at any point.

shoganai

9/30/22 3:36pm

They aren’t. They aren’t valid or relevant if they are misleading.

Coop

9/30/22 4:02pm

Again, if someone has the time and inclination to design and apply a balanced

shoganai

9/30/22 4:07pm

Good stats stop counting those plays/drives at end of blowout

rcbyufan

9/30/22 3:17pm

RE: Good stats stop counting those plays/drives at end of blowout

Coop

9/30/22 3:29pm

The issue isn’t yards per possession. But long drives.

Jcaps

9/30/22 4:08pm

Weber State's D is other worldly

machete

9/30/22 2:25pm

That is a very weird outlier.

shoganai

9/30/22 2:26pm

The game was a freak accident. Bonner threw two of the dumbest picks I've seen

Hotlanta

9/30/22 2:28pm

I have basically been saying our d is around average based on all the stats

Cougzilla

9/30/22 2:29pm

Bronco had a few mediocre defenses of his own through the years.

shoganai

9/30/22 2:30pm

Problem is a mediocre defense is a good year for Tuiaki.

ManicBlue

9/30/22 2:32pm

Agreed! we're about average. Question is if we're seeing upward trajectory

runnincoug

9/30/22 2:33pm

IMO, we won't see any upward trajectory until our recruiting improves.

shoganai

9/30/22 2:35pm

I don't disagree, so why is our recruiting improving in every area EXCEPT dline?

runnincoug

9/30/22 2:37pm

Per kotacoug it’s 100% scheme…I disagree but thought I’d speak for him today

9/30/22 2:41pm

Our most recent DL recruiting seems to be quite strong.

shoganai

9/30/22 2:44pm

I think that’s true. Hopefully the recent defensive line commitments really

TempeCoug

9/30/22 2:39pm

But we can lose a WR, DB, RB, OL person and have the depth to be fine

runnincoug

9/30/22 3:29pm

You won’t get an argument from me that defense needs better recruitment.

TempeCoug

9/30/22 4:21pm

87th in rushing yards allowed isn’t average

I'mBatman

9/30/22 2:55pm

Our run D is obviously our weakness. That was pretty well assumed coming into

shoganai

9/30/22 2:58pm

What’s the pass d ranked?

Cougzilla

9/30/22 3:28pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad