Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up
Nov 26, 2022
12:24:30pm
BYUCougarsFan All-American
Last year the team was fantastic. I give the HC a pass for this year, IF the
offseason fixes the defensive issue (aka bring in a defensive coordinator).

I don't HATE Tuiaki, but his defenses haven't been good. The "good" years they've been mediocre. The "bad" years they've been awful, like this year. If you have good coaches, then some years you'll have a great defense, some years bad. But this defense is either average or bad since Tuiaki was in charge. I wouldn't care too much about the occasional bad year IF they also had an occasional GREAT year.

The offense has followed this cycle, however. Some years we have a top-25 powerhouse offense (if the defense didn't suck, this year would be that year IMHO). Some years they'll be rebuilding... and our offense has seen that too. In the down years, I will NOT call for Roderick's job. He's had too many good years, and I expect it to be cyclical.

But our defense has never had a "great" year under Tuiaki (and frankly, I think it may be Kalani's defensive philosophy). I don't like the scheme. His whole philosophy is don't give up big plays, make it hard for them to get a touchdown, and THEN they'll make mistakes. Play prevent and make them beat you.

But it hasn't worked. Project failed.

Let's bring in someone who actually wants to get stops, not just play contain and hope for turnovers. That philosophy just hasn't worked. How many QB hurries do we get? Sacks? QBs just sit back, get comfortable, and pick us apart. RBs get 5 yards before they get contact. And no, we don't give up big plays. But the good teams don't make mistakes against us. We lose the TOP battle almost every game. This philosophy hasn't worked.

So yeah, new defense, new defensive philosophy, and new DC. That's what i want in the offseason.

But the offense and head coach? I'm very satisfied. They have had so many great years. Just need a defense to follow the same cycle as the offense: some great years, some rebuilding years. The years they match up and are both great are the special years.
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Nov 26, 2022 at 12:24:30pm
Message modified by BYUCougarsFan on Nov 26, 2022 at 12:25:08pm
Message modified by BYUCougarsFan on Nov 26, 2022 at 12:25:50pm
Message modified by BYUCougarsFan on Nov 26, 2022 at 12:26:29pm
Message modified by BYUCougarsFan on Nov 26, 2022 at 12:27:30pm
BYUCougarsFan
Bio page
BYUCougarsFan
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Last login
May 7, 2024
Total posts
37,942 (4,876 FO)
Messages
Author
Time
11/26/22 12:39pm
11/26/22 2:31pm

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.