His roster construction is not very good. If somehow he gets the right pieces together he will do fine. The problem is he seems to have a weakness with roster construction.
I also wouldn't say he was giftwrapped the roster his first two years though. He pulled a miracle to bring Childs back and he brought Toolson and Barcello with him to BYU. Following year he brought in Haarms and Averette which took BYU to a 6 seed. After that, it's been brutal.