That’s possible for any player though. If allgeier was on the giants he wouldn’t

Jan 25, 2023
8:22:15am

Cougzilla Political Junky

Have had as many touches right? Because Barkley is RB1. The only way to judge a player is how they performed in the situation they were placed, hardly seems fair to judge on hypotheticals.

Report problem with this ad

Cougzilla

Previous username: DOGDOR
Bio page: Cougzilla
Joined: Oct 6, 2011
Last login: Jan 23, 2024
Total posts: 3,783 (36 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Allgeier snubbed

fredetteaboutit13

1/25/23 7:47am

Brock Purdy?

LifeLongLakerFan

1/25/23 7:50am

It’s about flash not substance

DKN

1/25/23 7:50am

Big snub. Purdy will get recognized as he is the QB for a Super Bowl caliber team. Walker had the TDs.

RoaroftheCougartails

1/25/23 7:51am

Purdy is also undefeated as the starter… probably the most important stat.

Cougzilla

1/25/23 8:11am

For sure. He's done a great job. Insert his performance and record on a regular team and he's not in this convo though.

RoaroftheCougartails

1/25/23 8:13am

That’s possible for any player though. If allgeier was on the giants he wouldn’t

Cougzilla

1/25/23 8:22am

Im not judging(secretly I am on the Niners bandwagon right now) I'm just saying. If he does what he does on my team

RoaroftheCougartails

1/25/23 8:28am

If he went 7-0 on the cards he would get some run. But it wouldn’t be the same

Cougzilla

1/25/23 8:32am

He's not just some game manager on a good team, though.

BlueFever

1/25/23 8:26am

I disagree(and I am rooting for the Niners). He does enough to move the ball, makes as few mistakes as possible and

RoaroftheCougartails

1/25/23 8:34am

You should watch more than one game before developing an opinion

RealTaysomHill

1/25/23 8:51am

I watched all the niners game that were nationally televised so most of those 7.

RoaroftheCougartails

1/25/23 10:08am

Then I'm not sure how you didn't notice how much the 49ers offense opened up

RealTaysomHill

1/25/23 1:16pm

It's been nice to be able to run a true West Coast offense now that we have a QB who can throw to the sidelines.

-C9-

1/25/23 1:26pm

Or understand the game of football

-C9-

1/25/23 1:09pm

He's a smart player with a decent arm and he's mobile.

BlueFever

1/26/23 9:47am

I think he was a long shot. Most of the other predictions had him in next tier

Howard Bannister

1/25/23 7:51am

Purdy didn’t even play half a season

pink22

1/25/23 7:55am

And looked great in those games.

Jeffacka

1/25/23 8:03am

Ok…so what if he played 1 game? Or 2?

pink22

1/25/23 12:47pm

That didn't happen. You can play what if all day.

Jeffacka

1/25/23 3:21pm

well what rookie Qb would you like in over him? They only submit one RB for the

Mayor of Cougartown

1/25/23 8:05am

There has to be a QB involved in the final 3?

fredetteaboutit13

1/25/23 8:07am

the real question should be is did he have a better season than the RB listed

Mayor of Cougartown

1/25/23 10:53am

So there can be only one RB? I’m not saying Allgeier should win it. We are

fredetteaboutit13

1/25/23 5:06pm

To be fair, Allgeier didn't step in as RB1 until several games in either

Mises

1/25/23 8:07am

Neither did Walker

fredetteaboutit13

1/25/23 8:13am

I mean, Kenneth Walker was pretty incredible. Tough break but I get it.

CougarTailDevourer

1/25/23 8:01am

He’s not the one who snubbed him.

fredetteaboutit13

1/25/23 8:06am

It’s between Walker III and Wilson. It doesn’t really matter who else is/is not

RealTaysomHill

1/25/23 8:54am

Niners fan here, but no way should Purdy be on that list. Played like 4 games.

Mitty

1/25/23 9:49am

6 games. Instrumental in clinching the NFC West and overcoming Minnesota to be the #2 seed.

kirty

1/25/23 11:42am

Niners fan who doesn't even know how many games he played?

-C9-

1/25/23 1:07pm

Exactly. He's now started 7 and played pretty much the entire game before that

RealTaysomHill

1/25/23 1:14pm

I don't think people realize how incredible that Miami game was. He came in the second drive and took over.

-C9-

1/25/23 1:14pm

It should be Purdy.

ChandlerAZCoug

1/25/23 11:02am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad