Well, my wife, like Jessica Simpson, thought it really was chicken, but thought it was referring to chickens from Hawaii
or something. Yes, it was one of the funnier moments in our early marriage. I didn't let her forget it for sometime. She made a salad for a RS dinner and said, "the chicken tastes funny in this salad." I said "uh, that's not chicken. Where's the can?" She said "right here, it says chicken of the sea."
I literally couldn't breathe I was laughing so hard. I thought I was being put on. She still hates it when I bring it up.