I re-read the OP and didn’t get any of that. PortlandCoug just thought it would be a nice

Apr 14, 2024
10:34:15am

SJS Shaky place kicker

redemption story (and I agree).

Not sure why the idea that Burgess (a former BYU employee and by all known accounts good one) being named HC bothers you so much.

Report problem with this ad

SJS

Previous username: San Juan Sun
Bio page: SJS
Joined: Jan 5, 2002
Last login: May 16, 2024
Total posts: 37,703 (7,352 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Wouldn’t it be quite the story that of all the people in BYU basketball history

PortlandCoug

Apr 14, 8:37am

He was done wrong by BYU back in his player days, I think we all agree there

Heath Squashwell

Apr 14, 8:46am

How was he "done wrong" by BYU? He was offered a scholarship and went

LV Mike

Apr 14, 9:02am

Why shouldn’t Burgess have made that Reid story public?

scootsy

Apr 14, 9:12am

Yeah that story deserved to be told.

JoeExotic

Apr 14, 9:12am

Fine. But Burgess was not “done wrong” because he chose to publicly call out

LV Mike

Apr 14, 9:27am

He called out BYU as an institution?

SJS

Apr 14, 9:28am

He took a private conversation and made it public to humiliate BYU.

LV Mike

Apr 14, 9:38am

He did exactly what he should have. That needed to be exposed.

JoeExotic

Apr 14, 9:43am

Yeah, of all the things that need to be exposed with recruiting blue chip

MHOP

Apr 14, 10:28am

I would be wary of assigning motive to a comment made by a then 17 yo Burgess. And I would

SJS

Apr 14, 9:45am

No. I took exception to the OP premise that Burgess was "done wrong" by BYU.

LV Mike

Apr 14, 10:25am

I re-read the OP and didn’t get any of that. PortlandCoug just thought it would be a nice

SJS

Apr 14, 10:34am

Okay. My mistake. It wasn’t the OP but the first comment.

LV Mike

Apr 14, 12:50pm

He called out Roger Reid, who overestimated the number of disappointed Mormons

ledfoot

Apr 14, 3:27pm

Yes. So Burgess was “wronged” by BYU because its coach privately whined to him

LV Mike

Apr 14, 4:52pm

He was done wrong by Reid, who represented BYU as the HC

JoeExotic

Apr 14, 9:32am

Didn't see this before I posted, but it's almost word for word my thoughts

krindorr

Apr 14, 11:45am

Didn’t BYU basically fire Reid bc of that though? Which separates them.

Dr MoBYU

Apr 14, 2:54pm

No, Reid was fired for losing and not being able to recruit well, but he was

Threw and Through

Apr 14, 3:11pm

Burgess was done wrong by Roger Reid, who was acting in his capacity as a representative of the University

krindorr

Apr 14, 11:44am

Don't recall Burgess repeating it

mindzeYe

Apr 14, 1:15pm

We cannot all agree there. Roger

pappabear246

Apr 14, 11:30am

I think we can all agree that we don't agree on that - at all

Bill

Apr 14, 3:32pm

Do Robbie and/or Randy have sons that could possibly be recruited to BYU?

Manti

Apr 14, 8:46am

One at SUU right now

Kevin Arnold

Apr 14, 11:47am

If Utah had Men’s BBall fans, it would be reminiscent of KWhitt in Football in

Crowd Factor

Apr 14, 8:46am

They have fans……

kansascougar

Apr 14, 8:49am

You heard wrong.

Ozymandias

Apr 14, 8:55am

Yes blah blah you win attendance smack, we win for the court and in postseason.

Utefaninenemyland

Apr 14, 9:12am

“For the court and in postseason”

CPAcoug87

Apr 14, 9:20am

I'm sorry, but making the NCAA tourney > winning in the NIT

jreid191

Apr 14, 9:20am

Not if you are one and done and your coach bails

Utefaninenemyland

Apr 14, 11:49am

I've thought about that a lot the past couple days.

FootBackwards

Apr 14, 8:51am

"redemption for BYU"? I don't understand how BYU can be "redeemed" if it hires

LV Mike

Apr 14, 9:07am

I liked Roger Reid in general, but the Burgess thing was a huge embarrassment.

WVU_Prof

Apr 14, 11:13am

I agree that Reid was that what Reid did was bad and over the top. I also

LV Mike

Apr 14, 4:50pm

BYU's head coach (the representative of the University's basketball team)

FootBackwards

Apr 15, 12:46am

RE: Wouldn’t it be quite the story that of all the people in BYU

NOCAL_YFAN

Apr 14, 8:52am

No longer letting down millions of Mormons.

Real Men Wear Blue

Apr 14, 9:05am

17 million now so it’s a net positive.

Soupie

Apr 14, 9:24am

Basically a modern version of the Job story, since there’s 2x the membership now

d-coug

Apr 14, 9:10am

If he takes the BYU job and BYU struggles then he will have

JoeExotic

Apr 14, 9:14am

“9 million”

AZcougLawyer

Apr 14, 9:28am

If Burgess is hired by BYU he won't stay long enough to be a great coach

Cougrrrs Roll

Apr 14, 10:06am

<< Deleted >>

tony

Apr 14, 10:54am

Uh. Madsen doesn't have years of track record. Neither did Pope.

TheDash

Apr 14, 11:23am

That's a very inaccurate and poor response to my post

Cougrrrs Roll

Apr 14, 12:21pm

you still take him if he's the best available.

qwerew

Apr 14, 4:12pm

I don't doubt that

Cougrrrs Roll

Apr 14, 4:36pm

Signed Roger Reid

Pickleball Bill

Apr 14, 6:33pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad