You are debating something different. I’m looking at it from Pops perspective.

Report problem with this ad

Apr 27, 2024
5:28:42pm

cougaman Intervention Needed

He’s not going to Creighton if hall is going there, and hall coming to BYU opened up the spot at Creighton.

Report problem with this ad

cougaman

Bio page: cougaman
Joined: Mar 11, 2006
Last login: May 10, 2024
Total posts: 68,746 (4,481 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Hall decided to come back to BYU, and Isaac goes to creighton. Seems it was

cougaman

Apr 27, 4:45pm

Take hall anyday except for 2 last season

johnnybyu

Apr 27, 4:48pm

Kinda. We wanted both. We wanted both on the court at the same time quite a bit, even.

SinkingQuffa

Apr 27, 4:50pm

As of the last news, we are still in the top 5 for Blackmon from Stetson who is

cwilke1

Apr 27, 5:00pm

Yeah, I like him, but he's no Pop. I have no doubt Hall & Pop would've worked well together.

SinkingQuffa

Apr 27, 5:03pm

Pop is one of the most inefficient high volume players in cbb

BYU '80

Apr 27, 8:37pm

Sure we would have taken both, but was Pop considering playing with hall, or was

cougaman

Apr 27, 5:09pm

I highly doubt Hall's decision did anything lessen the importance of picking up Pop.

SinkingQuffa

Apr 27, 5:12pm

Yes, but did it lessen Pop's interest in coming to BYU?

cougarfan84

Apr 27, 5:15pm

It could've, maybe. Though Pop did whittle down his Final-3 cut after Hall announced his return, didn't he?

SinkingQuffa

Apr 27, 5:17pm

You are debating something different. I’m looking at it from Pops perspective.

cougaman

Apr 27, 5:28pm

He didn't kick us out after Hall's announcement, though. We made his final group.

SinkingQuffa

Apr 27, 6:29pm

So you don’t think that Hall choosing BYU weighed heavily on his decision? I

cougaman

Apr 27, 6:42pm

We needed both

Blue2thebone

Apr 27, 7:19pm

Creighton still has Ashworth? So I don't think it was one or the other or Isaac

cwilke1

Apr 27, 4:51pm

I have it on good authority losing Pop means it is illegal for BYU to have nice things.

JohnnyComeLately

Apr 27, 4:58pm

I just looked up and it seems that the sky is literally falling

Ojiisan

Apr 27, 5:22pm

Yeah I don't blame him

breakingblue

Apr 27, 5:01pm

Hall hands down especially w/Isaac's sexual assault allegations.

Forzaitalia

Apr 27, 5:39pm

Yeah, they were apparently dismissed, but just being in that conversation is

jaba166

Apr 27, 6:43pm

This is why people hate us. Judgment. We know nothing about him or what happened

ColonelMustard

Apr 27, 7:52pm

The Atonement works, just not for college Athletes

Born2Fish

Apr 27, 8:05pm

I'm not sure that stating the charges "may have been trumped up" equals

jaba166

Apr 27, 10:28pm

The thing that annoys me about Hall and Sanders... I'm happy both returned...

Coug

Apr 27, 5:54pm

true but almost every team in the country is dealing with same issues.

qwerew

Apr 27, 6:32pm

Not every team is like BYU where a certytype of individual matters

Coug

Apr 27, 7:47pm

true as well. BYU recruiting pool is smaller.

qwerew

Apr 27, 9:43pm

Well we now get to say a player big BYU over Kentucky

johnnybyu

Apr 27, 10:29pm

I agree, if it really came down to one or the other.

qwerew

Apr 27, 6:31pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad