My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 30, 2024
12:27
:50
pm
beefytee
All-American
Why go with 6 if it includes Stewart? Just go with 5. Huge divide after that.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
beefytee
Bio page
beefytee
Joined
Dec 18, 2003
Last login
May 21, 2024
Total posts
3,914 (1 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
QB recruiting since Lavell
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:10pm
What this tells me is the next great BYU quarterback might be on our roster, and
HenderCoug
Apr 30, 12:11pm
AROD has whiffed on plenty of talented QBs.
VB2
Apr 30, 5:12pm
Which ones did he whiff on that turned out to be a great QB?
donnerstag
Apr 30, 5:28pm
Are you saying we are not good at developing the QB at BYU?
MajorZeus
Apr 30, 12:12pm
2 things
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:15pm
I think you are right. Star rating is not a preview of things to come. Does such
MajorZeus
Apr 30, 12:16pm
There are, but the biggest indicator is the NFL draft where even the experts
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:33pm
Stewart was not a great QB.
kimdaddy35
Apr 30, 12:16pm
Agree, but belongs in the top 6 since 2002
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:18pm
Wasn't Mangum's freshman year better than Stewart's?
kimdaddy35
Apr 30, 12:19pm
The stats aren't super far apart, but Mangum did have better receivers
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:26pm
He didn't call him great. He said he was one of the 6 best since Lavell.
Rise Against
Apr 30, 12:21pm
He was decent, but doesn't belong with the others listed
Dr T-bone
Apr 30, 12:25pm
Why go with 6 if it includes Stewart? Just go with 5. Huge divide after that.
beefytee
Apr 30, 12:27pm
Stewart is still a good case study that recruit rankings don’t matter
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:40pm
If we have a Stewart as our QB in the Big 12 we are in big trouble
kimdaddy35
Apr 30, 1:10pm
Perhaps. He did well against a light schedule and saved a season from disaster
donnerstag
Apr 30, 1:20pm
I don't disagree. He played his role well. He just would never have been a good
kimdaddy35
Apr 30, 1:22pm
If we're being fair, there is a clear top 4 then a gap to Taysom and another gap
donnerstag
Apr 30, 12:28pm
That is some interesting data right there
Croweater
Apr 30, 12:39pm
Gadzooks, that’s a lotta homework. 👍
BleedCougarBlue2
Apr 30, 12:49pm
Wilson, Hill and both Halls were more highly recruited than the QBs currently
CaliforniaCougar22
Apr 30, 1:05pm
Facts Matter
ghettomagic
Apr 30, 2:16pm
Hall and Taysom actually signed with other schools
donnerstag
Apr 30, 2:27pm
I am saying you missed Zach signing out of HS with Boise St.
ghettomagic
Apr 30, 2:31pm
He didn't sign. He only committed. Big difference.
Rise Against
Apr 30, 2:38pm
Umm. I think your facts are wrong
Croweater
Apr 30, 3:18pm
Thats some quality data
AltTabbins
Apr 30, 3:19pm
Depending on how you count Heaps, BYU has had a future NFL QB on roster since
NYC and Japan
Apr 30, 11:11pm
Heaps was not an NFL QB. But 2006 had one who was drafted in the top 40
kimdaddy35
Apr 30, 11:15pm
Heaps was paid by NFL teams 3 years on practice squads, etc.
NYC and Japan
Apr 30, 11:20pm
I'm aware, but if you don't ever make an NFL team it is hard for me to call you
kimdaddy35
Apr 30, 11:27pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
