Apples and oranges.

Report problem with this ad

Nov 23, 2017
11:44:09am

BYUlv Contributor

Apples and oranges.

Report problem with this ad

BYUlv

Previous username: VegasScout
Bio page: BYUlv
Joined: Jun 22, 2006
Last login: May 23, 2024
Total posts: 1,504 (13 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU and the Green Bay Packers...two cautionary tales

holyyewtbatman

11/22/17 9:37pm

holy newt batman. nice post.

Cougarclaw

11/22/17 9:41pm

Couple problems with your example. First, BYU was healthy vs Portland, LSU, and

Blueto

11/22/17 9:44pm

RE: Couple problems with your example. First, BYU was healthy vs Portland, LSU,

holyyewtbatman

11/22/17 9:46pm

Your entire post is pride. Drop the pride and realize that we don't have a qb or

Phcole

11/22/17 9:47pm

RE: Your entire post is pride. Drop the pride and realize that we don't have a

holyyewtbatman

11/22/17 9:53pm

We have bad players at many more positions than two

ColumbusCoug

11/22/17 9:54pm

Tanner Mangum is a Elite 11 MVP who threw for 3500 yrs as freshman. Squally

Blueto

11/22/17 9:54pm

Squally transferee because he wasn’t going to see time at WSU...Tanner was given

ColumbusCoug

11/22/17 9:55pm

Our current players are not much worse than what BYU typically has. Sorry.

Blueto

11/22/17 9:58pm

Dude, in 2015 Algae Brown and "just not good" Mangum were our starting QB and RB

WSUV

11/23/17 12:09am

He threw those yards to one of our best receiving corps in the 21st century.

Phcole

11/22/17 10:05pm

Agreed, our talent is on par with where it was with Bronco.

Dynasty1

11/22/17 10:13pm

No its not. Who makes the NFL from this team? Though he didn't bring in a ton,

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:20pm

Mangum, Koroma, Kanuch, Linehan, Kaufusi, Taki Taki, Pauu, Warner, Hadley,

Dynasty1

11/22/17 10:25pm

We should beat those teams. Yes. NFL talent? No.

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:27pm

We didn't have a bunch of NFL talent a few years ago but yet could compete

Dynasty1

11/22/17 10:32pm

We did compete with lower P5 teams and G5. I thin Kalani carries a big part

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:35pm

Um...Bronco was notorious for having little to no NFL talent. In fact it's one

Blueto

11/22/17 10:30pm

Hill and Mangum looked NFL caliber under Bronco. No qb will ever look NFL caliber under Sitake.

Brisco

11/22/17 11:35pm

That Tanner Mangum doesn't exist anymore. No one cares about Elite 11 6 years

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:17pm

He was a freshman all American 2 years ago

Dynasty1

11/22/17 10:20pm

Actually taysom looked good last year, we just had no receivers.

Phcole

11/22/17 10:25pm

Statistically it was by far the worst year of his career

Dynasty1

11/22/17 10:30pm

He certainly wasn't as explosive last year, I was just talking about passing

Phcole

11/22/17 10:33pm

90% is pretty high. There were drops, but he couldn't throw last year either.

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:30pm

He also mssed 3 springs in a row.

BYURider

11/22/17 11:47pm

Tanner won't be in the NFL. He's digressed substantially. All the announcers

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:29pm

All in his own. It's so weird. Why did he choose to digress?

Blueto

11/22/17 10:32pm

Mental. Bad technique. Stares down WR. Inferior WRs.

CougarThug

11/22/17 11:59pm

Lol, that's a dumb question. Coaching is part of it. He can't run Detmers

IronPotato

11/23/17 7:51am

???

ColonelMustard

11/23/17 4:48pm

I'm guessing GB would beat Cleveland with their backup QB and RB.

mudpupper

11/22/17 9:56pm

Was going to post the same thing but figured someone else already had

ColonelMustard

11/23/17 8:55am

Agreed. Injuries have certainly taken a toll on the team. I still can't figure

CT98

11/22/17 9:47pm

The difference is that none of our QBs or RBs are any good. Rogers is a HOF.

IronPotato

11/22/17 10:09pm

So with Tanner we went 2-5... without... 1-3... about to be 1-4...

Coug

11/22/17 10:22pm

I have been saying this, my thoughts exactly

Y'sWoody

11/22/17 10:26pm

Um...those two situations aren’t remotely comparable.

RalphWiggam

11/22/17 10:39pm

RE: Um...those two situations aren’t remotely comparable.

holyyewtbatman

11/22/17 10:51pm

But the bigger point is this...why don’t we have solid QB okay?

RalphWiggam

11/22/17 11:03pm

I get your point 100%! And i dont get how others don't

BYURider

11/22/17 11:52pm

They are comparable as he said in follow up

SpudCoug

11/22/17 11:00pm

See above post. Why don’t we have good QB play? How did tanner regress so much

RalphWiggam

11/22/17 11:05pm

RE: See above post. Why don’t we have good QB play? How did tanner

holyyewtbatman

11/22/17 11:19pm

The offense has improved this year despite all the injuries and QB shuffle. But

BYURider

11/22/17 11:56pm

For the 100th time. This team might’ve looked the most unprepared,

Gerald-DeGroot

11/23/17 2:18am

Must. Resist. Agreeing. With. You...

gmoney7

11/23/17 8:35am

Apples and oranges.

BYUlv

11/23/17 11:44am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad