I wouldn't prefer Booby Knight over Rose; certainly not Stew.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 29, 2014
8:59:43pm

roseyscenario

I wouldn't prefer Booby Knight over Rose; certainly not Stew.

Rose is a good but not great coach. He is great at making friends for the Church and for BYU. As long as he wins 20 , he can stay forever, imo. And he will likely be closer to 30 wins for the next several years.

But he is no John Wooden, and probably not a Stan Watts. Rose is perfect for BYU and he might yet get them to the FF.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 29, 2014 at 8:59:43pm

Message modified by roseyscenario on Sep 30, 2014 at 6:15:48am

Report problem with this ad

roseyscenario

Previous username: addedupon
Bio page: roseyscenario
Joined: Jul 15, 2011
Last login: Jun 17, 2024
Total posts: 23,385 (4,059 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What's gotta hurt Stew worse: Having Dave swoop in & steal an

Mantis Mutu

9/29/14 7:59pm

Would Stu have ever come to coach at BYU anyway?

Polecat

9/29/14 8:01pm

If we had offered--probably. He interviewed back when Cleve was hired.

Mantis Mutu

9/29/14 8:05pm

Of course he would. Better program better city

Big Daddy D

9/29/14 8:16pm

In a second.

9/29/14 9:12pm

I kinda wanted Stew at one time also. But then I also wanted

Real G Man

9/29/14 8:02pm

I still wonder where ol' Kyle would've taken our program

Mantis Mutu

9/29/14 8:07pm

Stew is a member of the church? I had no idea.

newey-west

9/29/14 8:12pm

Definitely not active.

jakesnake

9/29/14 9:00pm

He played basketball at Provo High

9/29/14 10:09pm

Interesting, just saw that he had connections to Ricks College too.

newey-west

9/29/14 10:20pm

I like both coaches but IMO Stew is a better X's and O's coach

HawkCat

9/29/14 8:11pm

I think we would've seen a Roger Reid situation all over again.

Mantis Mutu

9/29/14 8:19pm

A lot of similarities (both the good and the bad)

dilbert

9/29/14 8:31pm

Kinda like Majerus & Reid as flip sides of the same coin.

Mantis Mutu

9/29/14 8:33pm

Overall, I prefer the Dave Rose style of coaching over the Reid/Stew/Majerus

dilbert

9/29/14 8:42pm

I agree. Very much.

Mantis Mutu

9/29/14 8:43pm

What "more" has Stew done? And "less" than who?

CosmoK

9/29/14 10:14pm

I do think that USU has been screwed with seeding worse than

9/29/14 10:21pm

Correct, and they were #1 seed in NIT. Lost 1st game of NIT at home.

CosmoK

9/29/14 10:45pm

You definitely need to get over the insult and win in the NIT.

9/29/14 10:49pm

I'm sure getting left out was BYU's fault...

Cyclogist

9/30/14 6:05am

Of course it was.

9/30/14 11:02am

screwed with seeding? I don't think so. It's about who you beat.

BlueK

9/30/14 8:31am

Well, Stew has won an NCAA tournament game as an underdog

BigBlue04

9/30/14 7:42am

I guess that is something.

CosmoK

9/30/14 9:28am

RE: I guess that is something.

BigBlue04

9/30/14 9:56am

his record at CSU was mediocre. At USU it was based on crappy schedules

BlueK

9/30/14 8:29am

I wouldn't prefer Booby Knight over Rose; certainly not Stew.

roseyscenario

9/29/14 8:59pm

What do you mean, "he is probably not a Stan Watts"?

Soy Celeste

9/29/14 11:37pm

Stan Watts was coach of BYU back when they won the NC when it was NIT

6th-Kamikaze-mission

9/30/14 12:19am

So my praise of the man was not high enough for you?

roseyscenario

9/30/14 6:11am

I'm sure he appreciates the rest of what you said

BlueK

9/30/14 8:35am

Let's compare records.

Soy Celeste

9/30/14 9:30am

Not talking about records.

roseyscenario

9/30/14 10:13am

I agree. Have a great day!

Soy Celeste

9/30/14 10:22am

Rose is already better than Stan Watts. And that says quite a bit

BlueK

9/30/14 8:34am

Which upperclassman prepster are you referring to?

SingleStrapBackpack

9/29/14 11:27pm

Andrus. Our incoming Frosh big.

Mantis Mutu

9/30/14 12:46pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad