Been a whole lot of 3 star guys play like 4 star players at BYU and a bunch of 4 stars play like 1 stars. If you had an All-(4)Star team at BYU, it probably wouldn't be very good.
Saying all 4 stars automatically make the team and anyone lower doesn't is stupid.
I guess if you had Heaps and Beck or Hall competing against each other on the same team, you'd cut the latter two.