Montana and a handful of other schools dominate Division II (or whatever it's called these days; too lazy to look it up right now). These schools absolutely tear it up and they do so consistently. Why aren't they getting called up?
If BYU goes G5, it might well tear it up. But at that point, we've just become the Montana of DII.
If we don't get a seat at the P5 table now, even if it's just a highchair at the makeshift kiddy table, we're going to be in big trouble.