Beck had to deal with rotating coordinators and offenses. First time he has...

Jul 26, 2014
1:30:16pm

friscokid

...the same offense and coordinator from one year to the next was that SR year and he tore it up. Max was very good with one offense and OC in place his whole run. But I will still take Beck based upon the surgeon he was in 06.

Report problem with this ad

friscokid

Bio page: friscokid
Joined: Jan 22, 2002
Last login: Jan 21, 2024
Total posts: 4,011 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

All-Bronco Era Team

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:14pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

7/26/14 1:17pm

I had to give Beck some leeway because he had to learn a new system

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:29pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

7/26/14 1:33pm

If I'm taking a player for his career, I take Max.

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:48pm

Beck had to deal with rotating coordinators and offenses. First time he has...

friscokid

7/26/14 1:30pm

I have a feeling that after this season, Fua will have a spot on the LB line.

BYUisLife

7/26/14 1:18pm

KVN says Fua will be better than him.

Byron McNertney

7/26/14 1:27pm

Not gonna happen, but I think Fua will have a great year.

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:47pm

Had he served a mission he'd be in KVN territory

HawkCat

7/26/14 5:12pm

Travis Bright over Braden Hansen

CoopDizz

7/26/14 1:19pm

I could've gone either way, Bright was good

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:22pm

Major sin leaving Bright off.

ag4cougs

7/27/14 2:16am

Hadley was a LBer, right?

flyusaf

7/26/14 1:20pm

Preston was a corner, Spencer an LB.

canadiancougar624

7/26/14 1:21pm

Ah, dumb me.

flyusaf

7/26/14 1:22pm

what about Tonga at FB?

Cougarclaw

7/26/14 1:22pm

He would be the clear #1 FB, but most All-Time teams just carry two HB's

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:35pm

Was Falslev really our best PR in 10 years? Dang

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 1:22pm

Stick AC back there

canadiancougar624

7/26/14 1:22pm

some argument to be made for OC on PR/KR

Cougarclaw

7/26/14 1:23pm

Is there even a close second? Last guy to return more than 1 punt for a td?

bluescholar

7/26/14 1:23pm

Almost entirely agree...

bluescholar

7/26/14 1:22pm

Pitta is the NCAA all-time leader in receiving for TE's

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:25pm

Like I said, I think you can't really go wrong with either.

bluescholar

7/26/14 1:28pm

I agree. hard choice but I think I might take Harline. Eathyn over Ziggy

friscokid

7/26/14 1:34pm

This was the debate, longevity of success vs highest ceiling

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:38pm

Give me Pitta all day, every day.

BYUisLife

7/26/14 2:13pm

Tough to Argue too much with Any of your Selections except maybe Tonga at FB

Dr T-bone

7/26/14 1:43pm

I'm fine with putting two HBs instead of a HB and FB

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 1:52pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

7/26/14 2:08pm

<< Deleted >>

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:25pm

I'm not sure if Jamal has done more than Curtis Brown quite yet.

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:53pm

Its not necessarily a "who has accomplished more" argument

CaliWG

7/26/14 3:10pm

I think you're having some recency bias.

flyusaf

7/26/14 3:24pm

You just stated what I was thinking

CaliWG

7/26/14 3:33pm

He also got more carries. Their YPC was the same over 2 years.

flyusaf

7/26/14 3:37pm

RE: He also got more carries. Their YPC was the same over 2 years.

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 3:46pm

You are comparing JW true frosh season to CB's Jr & Sr seasons

CaliWG

7/26/14 3:51pm

I get that. We'll see how Jamal does these next 1-2 years.

flyusaf

7/26/14 3:59pm

RE: I get that. We'll see how Jamal does these next 1-2 years.

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 4:03pm

lol @ Falslev. Hurt us almost as often as he helped. Has more muffed returns

byutx

7/26/14 3:42pm

Nice... Would love to see the stats showing he was as bad as the ground...

byu_coug

7/26/14 4:44pm

Nothing is made up. He had more muffs (4 at least) than TDs on punts. I can

byutx

7/26/14 4:54pm

Oh man, he did that ALL THE TIME. Let the punt roll, then get angry as he

fredgarvin

7/26/14 7:26pm

He was good when actually fielded punts. too many fair catches or let it roll

SpiffCoug

7/26/14 7:33pm

I can agree with that.

byutx

7/26/14 10:12pm

He was decent. Still under 10 yds/return.

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 10:19pm

My point wasn't that he was the greatest ever...

byu_coug

7/26/14 10:47pm

So he had 2 more touchdowns than anyone else you listed...

byu_coug

7/26/14 10:50pm

RE: Nice... Would love to see the stats showing he was as bad as the ground...

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 4:55pm

Curtis Brown over Williams IMO. But overall a very strong list.

MantiCoug

7/26/14 3:54pm

Brian Logan over JJ.

Hambone

7/26/14 3:56pm

^^^ This is the change I'd make too

tcherrin

7/26/14 4:04pm

Me too

Wazzucougsx2

7/26/14 5:36pm

Max Hall over Beck

Posting on CougarBoard