Its not necessarily a "who has accomplished more" argument

Jul 26, 2014
3:10:17pm

CaliWG

Its more of "who was the better player?" Right now Jamal is a better runner of the football than Curtis ever was. Though Curtis was better as a receiver and making plays in space after the catch than anyone since Bronco took over, including Harvey.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jul 26, 2014 at 3:10:17pm

Message modified by CaliWG on Jul 26, 2014 at 3:11:02pm

Report problem with this ad

CaliWG

Bio page: CaliWG
Joined: Feb 8, 2005
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 24,093 (1,535 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

All-Bronco Era Team

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:14pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

7/26/14 1:17pm

I had to give Beck some leeway because he had to learn a new system

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:29pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

7/26/14 1:33pm

If I'm taking a player for his career, I take Max.

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:48pm

Beck had to deal with rotating coordinators and offenses. First time he has...

friscokid

7/26/14 1:30pm

I have a feeling that after this season, Fua will have a spot on the LB line.

BYUisLife

7/26/14 1:18pm

KVN says Fua will be better than him.

Byron McNertney

7/26/14 1:27pm

Not gonna happen, but I think Fua will have a great year.

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:47pm

Had he served a mission he'd be in KVN territory

HawkCat

7/26/14 5:12pm

Travis Bright over Braden Hansen

CoopDizz

7/26/14 1:19pm

I could've gone either way, Bright was good

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:22pm

Major sin leaving Bright off.

ag4cougs

7/27/14 2:16am

Hadley was a LBer, right?

flyusaf

7/26/14 1:20pm

Preston was a corner, Spencer an LB.

canadiancougar624

7/26/14 1:21pm

Ah, dumb me.

flyusaf

7/26/14 1:22pm

what about Tonga at FB?

Cougarclaw

7/26/14 1:22pm

He would be the clear #1 FB, but most All-Time teams just carry two HB's

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:35pm

Was Falslev really our best PR in 10 years? Dang

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 1:22pm

Stick AC back there

canadiancougar624

7/26/14 1:22pm

some argument to be made for OC on PR/KR

Cougarclaw

7/26/14 1:23pm

Is there even a close second? Last guy to return more than 1 punt for a td?

bluescholar

7/26/14 1:23pm

Almost entirely agree...

bluescholar

7/26/14 1:22pm

Pitta is the NCAA all-time leader in receiving for TE's

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:25pm

Like I said, I think you can't really go wrong with either.

bluescholar

7/26/14 1:28pm

I agree. hard choice but I think I might take Harline. Eathyn over Ziggy

friscokid

7/26/14 1:34pm

This was the debate, longevity of success vs highest ceiling

CaliWG

7/26/14 1:38pm

Give me Pitta all day, every day.

BYUisLife

7/26/14 2:13pm

Tough to Argue too much with Any of your Selections except maybe Tonga at FB

Dr T-bone

7/26/14 1:43pm

I'm fine with putting two HBs instead of a HB and FB

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 1:52pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

7/26/14 2:08pm

<< Deleted >>

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:25pm

I'm not sure if Jamal has done more than Curtis Brown quite yet.

flyusaf

7/26/14 2:53pm

Its not necessarily a "who has accomplished more" argument

CaliWG

7/26/14 3:10pm

I think you're having some recency bias.

flyusaf

7/26/14 3:24pm

You just stated what I was thinking

CaliWG

7/26/14 3:33pm

He also got more carries. Their YPC was the same over 2 years.

flyusaf

7/26/14 3:37pm

RE: He also got more carries. Their YPC was the same over 2 years.

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 3:46pm

You are comparing JW true frosh season to CB's Jr & Sr seasons

CaliWG

7/26/14 3:51pm

I get that. We'll see how Jamal does these next 1-2 years.

flyusaf

7/26/14 3:59pm

RE: I get that. We'll see how Jamal does these next 1-2 years.

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 4:03pm

lol @ Falslev. Hurt us almost as often as he helped. Has more muffed returns

byutx

7/26/14 3:42pm

Nice... Would love to see the stats showing he was as bad as the ground...

byu_coug

7/26/14 4:44pm

Nothing is made up. He had more muffs (4 at least) than TDs on punts. I can

byutx

7/26/14 4:54pm

Oh man, he did that ALL THE TIME. Let the punt roll, then get angry as he

fredgarvin

7/26/14 7:26pm

He was good when actually fielded punts. too many fair catches or let it roll

SpiffCoug

7/26/14 7:33pm

I can agree with that.

byutx

7/26/14 10:12pm

He was decent. Still under 10 yds/return.

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 10:19pm

My point wasn't that he was the greatest ever...

byu_coug

7/26/14 10:47pm

So he had 2 more touchdowns than anyone else you listed...

byu_coug

7/26/14 10:50pm

RE: Nice... Would love to see the stats showing he was as bad as the ground...

southernfriedcougar

7/26/14 4:55pm

Curtis Brown over Williams IMO. But overall a very strong list.

MantiCoug

7/26/14 3:54pm

Brian Logan over JJ.

Hambone

7/26/14 3:56pm

^^^ This is the change I'd make too

tcherrin

7/26/14 4:04pm

Me too

Wazzucougsx2

7/26/14 5:36pm

Max Hall over Beck

Posting on CougarBoard