OK then your stance is that BM and Co are poor recruiters?

Report problem with this ad

Oct 23, 2014
12:42:19pm

Jkampana

Report problem with this ad

Jkampana

Bio page: Jkampana
Joined: Dec 10, 2008
Last login: Oct 28, 2015
Total posts: 8,140 (3,641 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Alisa says it's up to individuals to do their job. "Not the fans, not the coaches, not even your teammates on the sideline. It's you."#BYUSN View

@jaromjordan Jarom Jordan

10/23/14 10:39am

I disagree with Alisa - the coaches have a huge responsibility to get players

Bronoc

10/23/14 10:48am

He's taking responsibility for himself and saying that others on the team

binghammer

10/23/14 10:57am

he should take responsibility, but that doesn't absolve the coaches of theirs

Bronoc

10/23/14 10:59am

He doesn't need to worry about the coaches. He has a job to do and

binghammer

10/23/14 11:02am

you're right, he has no control over the coaches. But we can't pretend like a

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:06am

that's not what he said, you need to re-read the quote

binghammer

10/23/14 11:07am

it's nice to have that attitude, but it's not true

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:09am

You have some issues man. You have such an axe to grind w/ the coaches

binghammer

10/23/14 11:14am

yeah I have such a big axe to grind - that I say the coaches have responsibility

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:24am

no, just saying your comments are not relevant to the coaches, you said he was

binghammer

10/23/14 11:29am

I didn't say his attitude was wrong

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:32am

lol, that is essentially what he said

binghammer

10/23/14 11:33am

I think there is a difference

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:34am

I guess you do.

binghammer

10/23/14 11:36am

I agree. Bronco should learn from his players.

Jkampana

10/23/14 11:33am

Would you accept the hypothesis that the coaches have performed that task

StantonMac

10/23/14 11:02am

Are all the coaches acting in the same roles as previously?

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:07am

The only difference I know of is...

StantonMac

10/23/14 11:47am

The point being, the coaches have done their job, now the players need to do

Freddie Cougar

10/23/14 11:05am

have the coaches done their jobs?

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:07am

I think it would be silly to think otherwise

Freddie Cougar

10/23/14 11:29am

Does Nick Howell have a proven track record of calling a defense?

Bronoc

10/23/14 11:32am

We're talking about players doing their assignments

Freddie Cougar

10/23/14 11:37am

Pretty much everyone that understands football thinks the play calling is fine .

Jhayes

10/23/14 11:39am

There are plenty of instances where BYU teams have been unprepared in the past 5

Jkampana

10/23/14 11:48am

What does "unprepared" even mean, and how would a fan know?

StantonMac

10/23/14 12:00pm

Then why are we playing players that can't do their job?

Jkampana

10/23/14 12:35pm

Their backups can't do that job any better?

Jhayes

10/23/14 12:39pm

OK then your stance is that BM and Co are poor recruiters?

Jkampana

10/23/14 12:42pm

Ebbs and flows in talent ... BYU is not going to be awesome every year.

Jhayes

10/23/14 12:49pm

OK when is the swing going to go in favor of the BYU program maximizing talnent?

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:00pm

When the D was one of the top in the country was a good time.

Jhayes

10/23/14 1:00pm

Oh you mean the mighty 8-5 cougars.

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:07pm

Who says we haven't been maximizing talent?

StantonMac

10/23/14 1:05pm

Link?

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:12pm

Someone posted the latest study on the board within the last month or so

StantonMac

10/23/14 1:26pm

Sorry If I don't take your word for it.

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:47pm

Of course, that's the only possible explanation.

StantonMac

10/23/14 12:51pm

You believe coaching is fine. It's just players not executing?

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:03pm

I find it hilarious that guys like you refuse to put any blame on the players.

StantonMac

10/23/14 1:08pm

I do put blame on the players. In the end they are the ones on the field

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:11pm

Link to where I said the coaches have nothing to do with it?

StantonMac

10/23/14 1:25pm

This entire thread chain started my comment to FC concerning his comment that

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:47pm

such is the internet

StantonMac

10/23/14 1:49pm

I'm not saying that. So USU, UCF, Nevada, Virgina, etc. out executed us

Jkampana

10/23/14 1:14pm

Sometimes, just like being a parent, you do everything you can and your kids are

Jhayes

10/23/14 11:24am

It's nice he feels this way, but he's struggled.

Posting on CougarBoard