I disagree

Jan 28, 2015
1:27:35pm

gurt

I disagree

Jay is the one who was always shady. The one with the record and the one who consistently lied. I think he got involved in a shady drug deal and someone he knew did it. But not adnan.

Report problem with this ad

gurt

Bio page: gurt
Joined: Mar 15, 2007
Last login: Apr 28, 2024
Total posts: 11,950 (931 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Serial people: Is there anyone that doesn't think Adnan Sayed killed that girl?

riboflavin

1/26/15 11:02am

I think he was involved. somehow. either he knows who did it and was not

johnnycarson

1/26/15 11:04am

He doesn't have to be white to be innocent. What a terrible thing to say.

Epileptic Beagle

1/26/15 11:05am

RE: Serial people: Is there anyone that doesn't think Adnan Sayed killed that

foofcoug

1/26/15 11:08am

I don't necessarily think so. I don't know that I can believe anything Jay said

Non-donor troll

1/26/15 11:08am

yeah, i think convicting adnan from jay's testimony alone, should not have

johnnycarson

1/26/15 11:09am

Well that's the last time I trust an employee at a porn store then.

AndyDwyer

1/26/15 11:12am

It's not clear. Nothing in that story is clear. People who think

Memmo

1/26/15 11:12am

if he didn't do it, however, he's the unluckiest guy in the world. if only he

johnnycarson

1/26/15 11:14am

yeah, occam's razor isn't always right. in fact, it would be interesting to test

fattycoug

1/26/15 11:21am

Occam's razor doesn't really apply to fiction

DapperDan

1/26/15 11:45am

too much weirdness to feel super confident that he did it

fattycoug

1/26/15 11:17am

I'm 0 % convinced either way. My theory is Jay did it, was smart enough to go

Ebolarama

1/26/15 11:44am

people were complaining that adnan had no motive, but jay has even less of one.

riboflavin

1/26/15 11:57am

less of a reason that we know of.

fattycoug

1/26/15 12:10pm

Exactly, that we know of. Could have been a weirdo thinking he was helping Adnan

Ebolarama

1/26/15 1:06pm

Adnan and Jay did it, just not at the time the prosecution says

badodo

1/26/15 12:01pm

so why didn't adnan just implicate jay too? go down with him?

johnnycarson

1/26/15 12:12pm

He has a lot to lose in that scenario. Yes, he is locked up for life,

messi

1/26/15 12:28pm

I disagree

gurt

1/28/15 1:27pm

So what is the motive to kill Hae in this scenario?

flavordave

1/28/15 2:25pm

He got caught up in a drug deal so he killed Hae- huh?

messi

1/28/15 2:57pm

there are so

gurt

1/28/15 5:37pm

Have you seen the wire?

gurt

1/28/15 5:50pm

You mean the Adnan that was smoking weed all day with Jay the day his

flavordave

1/28/15 6:00pm

Its one thing to smoke weed recreationally with friends

gurt

1/28/15 6:03pm

Of course I've seen The Wire, I'm one of the board's TV experts.

messi

1/28/15 6:05pm

I think he probably did, but I don't understand how a jury could

Posting on CougarBoard