If you were black, non-Mormon, liked to drink, and have sex with your girlfriend (so pretty much every college kid in the flippin country) why in the name of all that's holy would you go BYU?!
I would never go, ever.
Comparing BYU to other D1 schools in recruiting is truly apples and oranges and always will be. You take away all the fun things about college and expect guys to come. They won't, they don't.
Look at Dave Rose numbers, he's 29 in career winning percentage all time! Line up every D1 coach of all-time, thousands upon thousands of great men and Dave is 29th in line. He's surrounded by the who's who of basketball legend. He will be in the College Basketball Hall of Fame one day and you're so short sighted you're bagging on him. Your stance is mind blowing. Get some perspective. Get real.