I knew I'd be flamed, but I think y'all are worked up into a lather to prove we

Jul 31, 2015
10:53:32pm

ray ray

are P5 but if you think objectively about it, BIG12 is not a very logical landing spot for us. It's the Pac12 or Indy. BIG12 locations for the most part are really bad matches for BYU.

Report problem with this ad

ray ray

Previous username: abe froman1
Bio page: ray ray
Joined: Sep 11, 2010
Last login: May 7, 2024
Total posts: 3,990 (8 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Pac12>Indy>Big12

ray ray

7/31/15 10:27pm

It isn't about location. It is about staying in the game.

Ragnar Danneskjold

7/31/15 10:28pm

This is one of the dumbest things people here say

seanyc17

7/31/15 10:29pm

Pac12>Big12>Indy>RES Poop>MWC

CougDogg-e-Dogg

7/31/15 10:29pm

Why not FCS w/byutv deal = 100% LDS footprint

mosterlow

7/31/15 10:30pm

Is our goal to stick within an LDS footprint?

mobius

7/31/15 10:32pm

Being in the LDS foot print is meaningless as far as this decision goes....

BengalCougar

7/31/15 10:36pm

I think if we got in the Big12 everyone would be excited to be in a p5 league

ray ray

7/31/15 10:37pm

RE: I think if we got in the Big12 everyone would be excited to be in a p5

BengalCougar

7/31/15 10:38pm

PAC12 >>>> Big XII>...∞-1...>Independent>>>MWC

Shimmy

7/31/15 10:37pm

We wouldn't want to extend our influence and message? Big12>pac12

travelcoug

7/31/15 10:38pm

I live in Texas, I haven't seen any new West Virginia dans around here. I'd

ray ray

7/31/15 10:41pm

Yeah, why would we want to recruit in places like Texas or Oklahoma?

flyusaf

7/31/15 10:53pm

How many Oklahoma recruits do you honestly think we'd be pulling as a BIG12

ray ray

7/31/15 10:57pm

More than we have now.

flyusaf

7/31/15 10:59pm

It would help in Texas, pretty marginally in the rest of the BIG12. It would

ray ray

7/31/15 11:05pm

It's not about landing recruits that would otherwise sign with OU. Sheeesh...

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 11:06pm

I don't disagree with this. I was addressing the claim that we'd be getting a

ray ray

7/31/15 11:34pm

You assume we'd regularly have USC/UCLA on the schedule

mobius

7/31/15 11:48pm

No, I don't, I'm trying to look at what a representative Indy schedule would

ray ray

7/31/15 11:52pm

You mean like 2017 where other than Utah we don't have any PAC12 games scheduled

mobius

7/31/15 11:57pm

hhhmm, why didn't you choose 2018?

ray ray

8/1/15 12:09am

Because with just one year I could prove your point wrong

mobius

8/1/15 12:22am

Stop exaggerating to make your point look better. I said on a representative

ray ray

8/1/15 12:27am

Right, we still have no idea what the average Indy schedule is like

mobius

8/1/15 12:43am

True, we don't know exactly what a long term Indy schedule looks like. That

ray ray

8/1/15 12:49am

So, you think 2/3 games annually against the PAC12 makes up for not being P5?

mobius

8/1/15 12:55am

cmon, where did I say that? I think Indy as a whole > BIG12 and that BIG12 makes

ray ray

8/1/15 1:06am

Indy means not P5. That's where you said it.

mobius

8/1/15 1:09am

Madness.

SJS

7/31/15 10:39pm

ray ray is cray cray

flyusaf

7/31/15 10:43pm

dang it!

SwampCougar

7/31/15 10:45pm

It's cool, great minds think alike.

flyusaf

7/31/15 10:46pm

I was just thinking that too- you're awesome!

SwampCougar

7/31/15 10:47pm

RE: Pac12>Indy>Big12=CRAY-CRAY

SwampCougar

7/31/15 10:44pm

Feces > Your Post > University of Utah

Walter Bellhaven

7/31/15 10:50pm

I knew I'd be flamed, but I think y'all are worked up into a lather to prove we

ray ray

7/31/15 10:53pm

Bronco disagrees. BYU has more in common

SaintGeorgeYFan

7/31/15 10:56pm

Praytell, why are Texas, Oklahoma, etc. a "bad match" for BYU?

flyusaf

7/31/15 10:56pm

Thats like saying why is playing BSU bad for us. Yes, the UT and OU games would

ray ray

7/31/15 11:01pm

And?????

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 11:03pm

So by that logic, we should join the MWC? The point is just looking at BIG12

ray ray

7/31/15 11:07pm

BYU stays Indy, BYU becomes irrelevant. If you can't see that, I can't help you.

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 11:29pm

No, not true

ray ray

7/31/15 11:35pm

Yes, absolutely true. You're living in Oz.

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 11:50pm

No, not true even if you stomp your feet. I live in Texas, blessed land

ray ray

8/1/15 12:09am

You should be more informed about college football then.

Kerbouchard

8/1/15 12:14am

you sure proved your point, well done, you clearly know A LOT

ray ray

8/1/15 12:18am

Those places have great game day atmosphere, which is what I would go for.

flyusaf

7/31/15 11:04pm

Yup! WVU, ISU and Texas Tech are awesome game weekend destinations.

TechTexan

8/1/15 7:47am

You should try and get to Bronco and talk some sense into him

Walter Bellhaven

7/31/15 10:57pm

Oh the irony of this board pointing Bronco as the definitive source of what is

ray ray

7/31/15 11:03pm

In this case, he's absolutely right. You make zero sense.

flyusaf

7/31/15 11:05pm

Ok, if flyusaf says so I'm sure it is right

ray ray

7/31/15 11:09pm

He is right in this case, you think the cities these games are played in are...

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:12pm

I don't see money as mattering much, we have sufficient already, recruiting I

ray ray

7/31/15 11:38pm

Money helps with every thing, both Holmoe and Bronco have made comments...

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:44pm

That's one way of looking at it.

Walter Bellhaven

7/31/15 11:06pm

that makes me an idiot if we take your idiotic definitive statements as truth

ray ray

7/31/15 11:10pm

LOL! Who's "we"?

Walter Bellhaven

7/31/15 11:13pm

You aren't following the logic, "we" would be anyone reading your statement

ray ray

7/31/15 11:17pm

The problem is, you're the only one that disagrees with me

Walter Bellhaven

7/31/15 11:43pm

If I can prove I'm not "the only one" will you admit your definitive statements

ray ray

7/31/15 11:49pm

Walter Bellhaven

8/1/15 12:10am

Didn't think so

ray ray

8/1/15 12:21am

No? Youre the only one then?

Walter Bellhaven

8/1/15 12:31am

I thought we went over this already. Are you willing to admit to the idiocy if

ray ray

8/1/15 12:38am

RE: I thought we went over this already. Are you willing to admit to the idiocy

Walter Bellhaven

8/1/15 1:03am

Didnt think so

ray ray

8/1/15 1:08am

You seem to be about the only person on earth that actually thinks Indy

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 11:32pm

I've seen plenty on here agree with this, certainly a minority but let's not

ray ray

7/31/15 11:40pm

And this is why you don't have Tom Holmoe's job. You still have not even

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 11:01pm

No it's not why

ray ray

7/31/15 11:14pm

Yes-doubling down holding 12 and dealer showing an ace. Good job- /s The Donald

SwampCougar

7/31/15 11:04pm

Like I said in previous posts, the locations don't really matter. You seem to..

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:04pm

And you have not said why Indy is better than the Big 12.

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:06pm

How is the Big 12 locations worse than Indy locations? Not trolling but fail to

fiberpost

7/31/15 11:16pm

Because outside of UT and OU I don't see any other games that I'd rather play on

ray ray

7/31/15 11:26pm

Better opponents overall is debatable, recruiting would be better in...

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:29pm

I think the better recruits is debatable, probably right but not by the margin

ray ray

7/31/15 11:42pm

Money impacts every thing, and if others have a lot more we are going to...

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:47pm

money and recruits are both debatable. What is the marginal benefit of more

ray ray

8/1/15 12:01am

RE: money and recruits are both debatable. What is the marginal benefit of more

BengalCougar

8/1/15 12:11am

I don't think money is our problem, I could be wrong but I don't buy it. IMO

ray ray

8/1/15 12:15am

It's not a problem right now, but it will be. You are ignoring that the two...

BengalCougar

8/1/15 10:51am

Yes, I have inside knowledge above and beyond TH and Bronco. But I won't share.

ray ray

8/1/15 11:29am

Money is a concern...from this POV

Heinz57

8/1/15 11:41am

I defy you to go to football games in...

Modiolus

7/31/15 10:57pm

I've been to games in most of those locations. I didn't say the experience sux

ray ray

7/31/15 11:13pm

And you have yet to say why Indy is better than the Big 12, let's hear some...

BengalCougar

7/31/15 11:24pm

Big12 fans >>>> pac12 fans. I'd rather associate with big12 schools any day

YIsForBrigham

7/31/15 10:59pm

Good grief...Shirley you can't be serious.

Kerbouchard

7/31/15 10:59pm

Outside LDS footprint = missionary opportunity?

Reasonable1

7/31/15 11:03pm

LDS footprint, lol

SBJ

7/31/15 11:13pm

I don't disagree that in an ideal world, the Pac-whatever is where we should be.

ataylor

8/1/15 12:06am

Well, you're wrong on this one. At least your mother still loves you.

swingcat

8/1/15 1:20am

This is the worst post I've read since the one that brought me out of retirement

Posting on CougarBoard