I would have to add the Cotton Bowl win over Kansas State and maybe include the win over Texas A&M from 1996 as well.

I would probably expand the list to 10 and include the games that you had in your list plus the Steve Young win over Mizzu in the Holiday Bowl.

I would include the BYU win over Wyoming in the WAC championship game. The game went into OT and was low scoring but exciting.

Either way, your list is a fun and nostalgic read. I would probably list the Miami game as number one because I was at that game and I didn't get to attend the comeback game (so I admit that I'm a tad biased on that front).