I likely would leave it as honorable mention but was an exciting game that BYU won in OT, and put us in the Sugar Bowl.
I also agree with the 52-52 tie being in the top 5, was a great game. It is also worth noting we could have won that game by going for 2 but chose to kick the extra point, more of a sure thing, since a tie would give us the WAC championship. If you talk to long time SDSU fans, this is a game that still haunts them.