I love THill as much as anyone. If we were guaranteed a full season of him healthy and as explosive as the old Taysom, it would be very hard not to want him back. But...
1 - He won't stay healthy. History don't lie and history says we wouldn't see a full season (or even close to a full season) from him. I wish this was untrue, but it's just not.
2 - Are you willing to risk Tanner leaving the program or regressing due to sitting for a full year? Again I love Taysom, but 3 years of Tanner is better than one of Taysom. Period.
3 - Remember what happened last time the program played musical chairs with QBs? Me neither. The Riley/Heaps era has been removed from memory due to its painful nature.