My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 8, 2015
2:35
:41
pm
AZcougLawyer
2- if Tanner sits a year, that means Hill played the whole year well.
That's an acceptable result.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
AZcougLawyer
Bio page
AZcougLawyer
Joined
Oct 27, 2009
Last login
Apr 28, 2024
Total posts
8,628 (96 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Love Mangum but don't understand why few don't want Hill back. #hillisawinner
MajorZeus
10/8/15 2:11pm
If Tanner keeps climbing I'd hope for a platoon if they're both up for it.
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:13pm
No. No. A million times, no.
RichieRich
10/8/15 2:21pm
Why? Cuz you're fearful two talented, agreeable QBs might give us
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:25pm
give an example of it working really well please.
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:27pm
Typically, college guys aren't mature enough to handle it.
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:31pm
way to avoid actually answering
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:33pm
Tell me of another program where a 23 year old Soph with NFL aspirations
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:40pm
a 23 year old sophomore with NFL aspirations would actually want to be in the
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:45pm
& if he wants to share the spotlight we the downed leader from the year before??
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:49pm
good luck with the platoon disaster
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:50pm
not going to be much of a spotlight.
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:50pm
I'd take Taysom & Tanner over a very good Max Hall for one simple reason.
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:53pm
Arizona 1998
Blue Cat
10/8/15 2:42pm
Ohio St. 1996
Blue Cat
10/8/15 2:45pm
Northwestern 2012
Blue Cat
10/8/15 2:46pm
looking at the stats
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:48pm
Notre Dame 2012 (somewhat)
Blue Cat
10/8/15 2:49pm
but not really
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:52pm
Golson took most of the snaps, but they brought Rees in for clutch situations.
Blue Cat
10/8/15 2:54pm
Because it is a failed model. That's not my opinion, that's a fact.
RichieRich
10/8/15 2:38pm
Um, Riley Nelson and Jake Heaps disagree with you pal.
MantiCoug
10/8/15 2:46pm
No. no. no. It's not the
ideal
model. And in times it's a prudent
mantis mutu
10/8/15 2:47pm
Should be a curse word in football.
Walter Bellhaven
10/8/15 2:22pm
When was the last time a platoon at qb actually worked well? Maybe Tebow at FL
Bubba Gravity
10/8/15 2:22pm
People fear the QB platoon system. It rarely works
TNT
10/8/15 2:13pm
If McMahon can redshirt for Wilson .....
youngbuck
10/8/15 2:14pm
19 yr old Soph compared to 23 yr old soph
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:15pm
#Hillisthebestathleteonanyfield
Bluesangue
10/8/15 2:15pm
I think people just don't want another midseason QB switch
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:17pm
But given Tanners experience if it happened i dont think it would be as bad as
monkeycowboy
10/8/15 2:19pm
I still don't like it.
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:21pm
The argument could also be made that if tanner goes down it wont be pretty...
monkeycowboy
10/8/15 2:24pm
Tanner's also less likely to get hurt I'd argue.
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:25pm
Even if this were true (& it's not), QB is not primarily an athlete's position.
mantis mutu
10/8/15 4:14pm
I'll give you a few
HRCougar
10/8/15 2:15pm
1 and 3 are legit reasons and why I would rather stay with Tanner.
WJCougar
10/8/15 2:18pm
4. It hurts Tanner's pro chances
HiLife
10/8/15 2:19pm
I don't want another Riley/Heaps. What scenario works for both?
MajorZeus
10/8/15 2:19pm
2- if Tanner sits a year, that means Hill played the whole year well.
AZcougLawyer
10/8/15 2:35pm
Perhaps in Hogwarts. But in real life, Tanner is shafted with TH back.
TeeKaa
10/8/15 3:42pm
Because three season-ending injuries in four years.
SandYFan
10/8/15 2:17pm
I'm kind of on the other side. I honestly think Mangum has the ability to be
hansel
10/8/15 2:18pm
Too much of a chance that he'll end up injured again - - - Season. Shot.
lightmann
10/8/15 2:18pm
Because #HillIsAWinner but #HillIsOnlyAWinnerIfHesOnTheField
Walter Bellhaven
10/8/15 2:21pm
#areyoumysister #hashtageverythingiwrite
byujag
10/8/15 2:35pm
Give me Taysom, or give me death!
RichieRich
10/8/15 2:23pm
Hopefully you die, for the sake of the program.
Walter Bellhaven
10/8/15 2:24pm
you can have him for a few games! :'(
Mr Bassman
10/8/15 2:24pm
Tanner is our future. Keep Tanner progressing and if Taysom wants to come back
rggee
10/8/15 2:28pm
No way. Keys to the kingdom belong to Tanner.
Walter Bellhaven
10/8/15 2:29pm
I think we agree...
rggee
10/8/15 2:35pm
So no Taysom QB snaps at BYU ever again as long as Tanner is healthy?
Walter Bellhaven
10/9/15 8:56am
I stand corrected
rggee
10/9/15 11:00am
I want Taysom back! Because, what if...
J-Rant
10/8/15 3:56pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad
