I don't want another Riley/Heaps. What scenario works for both?

Report problem with this ad

Oct 8, 2015
2:19:45pm

MajorZeus

Report problem with this ad

MajorZeus

Bio page: MajorZeus
Joined: Nov 25, 2012
Last login: May 11, 2024
Total posts: 14,640 (6 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Love Mangum but don't understand why few don't want Hill back. #hillisawinner

MajorZeus

10/8/15 2:11pm

If Tanner keeps climbing I'd hope for a platoon if they're both up for it.

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:13pm

No. No. A million times, no.

RichieRich

10/8/15 2:21pm

Why? Cuz you're fearful two talented, agreeable QBs might give us

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:25pm

give an example of it working really well please.

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:27pm

Typically, college guys aren't mature enough to handle it.

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:31pm

way to avoid actually answering

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:33pm

Tell me of another program where a 23 year old Soph with NFL aspirations

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:40pm

a 23 year old sophomore with NFL aspirations would actually want to be in the

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:45pm

& if he wants to share the spotlight we the downed leader from the year before??

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:49pm

good luck with the platoon disaster

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:50pm

not going to be much of a spotlight.

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:50pm

I'd take Taysom & Tanner over a very good Max Hall for one simple reason.

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:53pm

Arizona 1998

Blue Cat

10/8/15 2:42pm

Ohio St. 1996

Blue Cat

10/8/15 2:45pm

Northwestern 2012

Blue Cat

10/8/15 2:46pm

looking at the stats

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:48pm

Notre Dame 2012 (somewhat)

Blue Cat

10/8/15 2:49pm

but not really

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:52pm

Golson took most of the snaps, but they brought Rees in for clutch situations.

Blue Cat

10/8/15 2:54pm

Because it is a failed model. That's not my opinion, that's a fact.

RichieRich

10/8/15 2:38pm

Um, Riley Nelson and Jake Heaps disagree with you pal.

MantiCoug

10/8/15 2:46pm

No. no. no. It's not the ideal model. And in times it's a prudent

mantis mutu

10/8/15 2:47pm

Should be a curse word in football.

Walter Bellhaven

10/8/15 2:22pm

When was the last time a platoon at qb actually worked well? Maybe Tebow at FL

Bubba Gravity

10/8/15 2:22pm

People fear the QB platoon system. It rarely works

TNT

10/8/15 2:13pm

If McMahon can redshirt for Wilson .....

youngbuck

10/8/15 2:14pm

19 yr old Soph compared to 23 yr old soph

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:15pm

#Hillisthebestathleteonanyfield

Bluesangue

10/8/15 2:15pm

I think people just don't want another midseason QB switch

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:17pm

But given Tanners experience if it happened i dont think it would be as bad as

monkeycowboy

10/8/15 2:19pm

I still don't like it.

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:21pm

The argument could also be made that if tanner goes down it wont be pretty...

monkeycowboy

10/8/15 2:24pm

Tanner's also less likely to get hurt I'd argue.

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:25pm

Even if this were true (& it's not), QB is not primarily an athlete's position.

mantis mutu

10/8/15 4:14pm

I'll give you a few

HRCougar

10/8/15 2:15pm

1 and 3 are legit reasons and why I would rather stay with Tanner.

WJCougar

10/8/15 2:18pm

4. It hurts Tanner's pro chances

HiLife

10/8/15 2:19pm

I don't want another Riley/Heaps. What scenario works for both?

MajorZeus

10/8/15 2:19pm

2- if Tanner sits a year, that means Hill played the whole year well.

AZcougLawyer

10/8/15 2:35pm

Perhaps in Hogwarts. But in real life, Tanner is shafted with TH back.

TeeKaa

10/8/15 3:42pm

Because three season-ending injuries in four years.

SandYFan

10/8/15 2:17pm

I'm kind of on the other side. I honestly think Mangum has the ability to be

hansel

10/8/15 2:18pm

Too much of a chance that he'll end up injured again - - - Season. Shot.

lightmann

10/8/15 2:18pm

Because #HillIsAWinner but #HillIsOnlyAWinnerIfHesOnTheField

Walter Bellhaven

10/8/15 2:21pm

#areyoumysister #hashtageverythingiwrite

byujag

10/8/15 2:35pm

Give me Taysom, or give me death!

RichieRich

10/8/15 2:23pm

Hopefully you die, for the sake of the program.

Walter Bellhaven

10/8/15 2:24pm

you can have him for a few games! :'(

Mr Bassman

10/8/15 2:24pm

Tanner is our future. Keep Tanner progressing and if Taysom wants to come back

rggee

10/8/15 2:28pm

No way. Keys to the kingdom belong to Tanner.

Walter Bellhaven

10/8/15 2:29pm

I think we agree...

rggee

10/8/15 2:35pm

So no Taysom QB snaps at BYU ever again as long as Tanner is healthy?

Walter Bellhaven

10/9/15 8:56am

I stand corrected

rggee

10/9/15 11:00am

I want Taysom back! Because, what if...

J-Rant

10/8/15 3:56pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad