1-loss (Indy) = NY6; 1-loss (AAC) = NY6
2-loss (Indy) = Lower tier bowl; 2-loss (AAC) = Lower tier bowl
Better schedule = Indy
Better TV distribution = Indy
Lower chance of getting screwed over by conference/commissioner = Indy
Certificate on wall for AAC title = AAC
I'm not seeing the benefits of AAC ... unless the AAC championship sends thrills up your leg.