Oh don't get me wrong, as a BYU fan, I LOVE the idea. I just don't see any reason for ND to think it's a great idea.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 28, 2015
11:06:01am

LiveCoug All-American

Oh don't get me wrong, as a BYU fan, I LOVE the idea. I just don't see any reason for ND to think it's a great idea.

Report problem with this ad

LiveCoug

Bio page: LiveCoug
Joined: Aug 26, 2001
Last login: May 10, 2024
Total posts: 112,461 (11,510 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If Notre Dame is shut out of the playoff

JohnnyComeLately 3rd String

11/28/15 10:49am

LOL.. an independents championship game wouldn't do them much good.

LiveCoug

11/28/15 10:51am

If there was one this season, it could mean the difference between

Walter Bellhaven

11/28/15 10:52am

Really? You think playing an unranked BYU team would do a lick of good?

LiveCoug

11/28/15 10:54am

Ask Baylor and TCU what not playing on the last week did for them last season.

Walter Bellhaven

11/28/15 10:57am

What in the world? So, say BYU is 5-7. Are you saying it is better for ND

LiveCoug

11/28/15 10:59am

When was he last time either BYU or ND was 5-7?

JohnnyComeLately

11/28/15 11:00am

Ok, how about 8-4? 7-5? 9-3? A team on the brink of the playoffs would not benefit from

LiveCoug

11/28/15 11:02am

No.

Walter Bellhaven

11/28/15 11:03am

Its been brought up by ESPN

JohnnyComeLately

11/28/15 10:54am

What if BYU is 5-7 one year? That would just hurt them. There aren't enough independent teams to guarantee a good foe

LiveCoug

11/28/15 10:56am

So if you want to play the what if game

JohnnyComeLately

11/28/15 10:58am

In that case, great game. But that would be rare. With only 3 indy teams (and one being

LiveCoug

11/28/15 11:00am

I don't see a scenario where playing Notre dame every year on championship week is a bad idea

JohnnyComeLately

11/28/15 11:04am

Oh don't get me wrong, as a BYU fan, I LOVE the idea. I just don't see any reason for ND to think it's a great idea.

LiveCoug

11/28/15 11:06am

A thirteenth game on championship week against a top 50 team keeps you from

travelcoug

11/28/15 11:18am

OSU played the 13 ranked team in the country last year, big difference from playing 50th ranked

LiveCoug

11/28/15 11:32am

The top 15 would be nice but a thirteenth game against a top 50 on that week is

travelcoug

11/28/15 11:35am

Don't confuse them with facts. It is so much more fun to eor

travelcoug

11/28/15 10:56am

I disagree -- at least this year.

TrueTrue

11/28/15 10:56am

It absolutely would. If they remove the requirement to have 12 team this would

travelcoug

11/28/15 11:04am

An Indy Champ Game for all THREE teams? Yeah, that will really go over well.

Kerbouchard

11/28/15 10:51am

I would bet that a Notre dame BYU game on championship weekend

JohnnyComeLately

11/28/15 11:09am

If they really thought a game vs BYU would help, I'm sure they have TH's number

swingcat

11/28/15 10:53am

Calling BYU now is for one of 12 games a 13th game on championship week would be different.

JohnnyComeLately

11/28/15 10:55am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad