It's the exact opposite. Rose held Carlino accountable and MC wouldn't

Feb 7, 2016
7:05:53pm

Iman23 All-American

accept his changed/lessened (though more effective) role, so he left.

Saying that Rose didn't hold Carlino accountable is off base.

Report problem with this ad

Iman23

Bio page: Iman23
Joined: Jan 18, 2008
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 42,534 (2,708 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Dave Rose inadvertently caused all of the problems we are seeing with this team

byuschrein

2/7/16 11:34am

Nice try.

WJCougar

2/7/16 11:50am

About what was he wrong?

WhyKnot

2/7/16 11:56am

The free wheeling offense was a result of Jimmer

concolor couguar

2/7/16 11:58am

You don't know that it wasn't. His argument is better than yours so far.

WhyKnot

2/7/16 12:02pm

Did you watch BYU basketball before 2010?

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:05pm

Definitely. Long before.

WhyKnot

2/7/16 12:45pm

Jimmer put it on the national stage.Why else would Carlino and Fischer Transfer?

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:03pm

Fischer because his former coach was at BYU

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:04pm

Jonathan Tavernari too!

concolor couguar

2/7/16 11:50am

He shot a lot but i'm talking about the shots 6 feet behind the line

byuschrein

2/7/16 11:53am

There might be like 3 of those shots this whole year

concolor couguar

2/7/16 11:56am

Are you serious?? Do you watch the games? 3 per game more like

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:01pm

6 feet behind the line? Absolutely

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:01pm

Ok Mr. literal. NBA range and beyond or in other words.. Jimmer Range

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:13pm

Then your words are back to including JT he took plenty of deep 3s

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:14pm

Read the above posts. Rose has always given the green light but Jimmermania

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:27pm

Both were buried on the bench at their former schools both left

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:35pm

They were buried on the bench because of poor shot selection!!

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:35pm

That is ridiculous they were buried on the bench because they couldn't defend

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:38pm

Use the google machine and type in Matt Carlino UCLA Shot Selection

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:39pm

Matt Carlino never took a shot at UCLA

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:46pm

Quote from Chase Fischer on why he transferred to BYU:

byuschrein

2/7/16 12:43pm

All of which existed before Jimmer and does not support that he didn't play at

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:47pm

RE: Quote from Chase Fischer on why he transferred to BYU:

concolor couguar

2/7/16 12:50pm

You realize Chase transferred because he was buried on the bench?

WJCougar

2/7/16 12:57pm

How many times do you think Jimmer scored 50?

concolor couguar

2/7/16 11:54am

Good points, actually

WhyKnot

2/7/16 11:55am

Yes, the problems are systemic. Talent won't solve everything.

ag4cougs

2/7/16 12:35pm

So many factual errors in this post it's hard to take the opinion seriously.

StantonMac

2/7/16 12:43pm

Glad I'm not the only one that was thinking that.

Cougarrrs

2/7/16 1:20pm

True. And I think that sometimes

davidnairn

2/7/16 1:42pm

Its ok ti admit that occasionally BYU can do things wrong.

Backcountry

2/7/16 1:49pm

It's also ok to use actual facts as the basis for opinions

StantonMac

2/7/16 4:39pm

Chase Fischer has been a bright spot this year.

No touching

2/7/16 1:48pm

It's his philosophy. He recruits these guys to shoot. The come here to shoot.

Cougarfan777

2/7/16 1:49pm

I agree with much of this

braddahmike

2/7/16 1:51pm

There are times when players don't follow the coaching.

No touching

2/7/16 1:55pm

With regard to Emery,

No touching

2/7/16 1:51pm

Spot on...Could not have explained it better!

Coug76

2/7/16 3:26pm

Agreed. Basketball went downhill when

bigjohn

2/7/16 3:45pm

It's the exact opposite. Rose held Carlino accountable and MC wouldn't

Iman23

2/7/16 7:05pm

The play speaks for itself

bigjohn

2/8/16 7:25am

I think you are definitely correct about the Teams lack of Defense

BBarton

2/7/16 4:45pm

RE: Dave Rose inadvertently caused all of the problems we are seeing with this

Opietheman

2/7/16 7:43pm

Spot. Freaking. On.

El Boricua

2/7/16 8:43pm

There's truth to this unfortunately.

Gerald-DeGroot

2/7/16 9:11pm

halford shot 48% from three as senior. not sure why you would complain about him

lukeskywalker

2/8/16 9:55am

He did shoot well but struggled to guard with his lack of speed/quickness.

BBarton

2/8/16 12:07pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad