My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Feb 8, 2016
8:21
:28
am
Bravescoug
Starter
Why are people mocking the 39 year old winning QB
When the 26 year old MVP losing QB played much worse?
This message has been modified
Originally posted on Feb 8, 2016 at 8:21:28am
Message modified by Bravescoug on Feb 8, 2016 at 8:22:35am
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Bravescoug
Previous username
Brave pug
New username
Mr. Belding
Bio page
Bravescoug
Joined
Oct 18, 2013
Last login
Jan 1, 2017
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Related Threads
Topic:
Broncos win despite Manning. If I remember correctly he wasn't stellar the last time he won. Still one of the all time
(SouthernBlueBlood, Feb 8, 2016 at 7:06am)
Other Related Threads:
<< Deleted >>
(Bravescoug, Feb 8, 2016 at 8:21am)
Messages
Author
Time
Why are people mocking the 39 year old winning QB
Bravescoug
2/8/16 8:21am
They're ageists.
Hoosier Cougar
2/8/16 8:22am
Because he played like crap and he is the worst QB to have ever won a super bowl
Josef K
2/8/16 8:23am
You serious? This is a silly statement, he had a terrible season, but was not
JOPE
2/8/16 8:29am
Dilfer was much better than Manning.
Josef K
2/8/16 8:34am
RE: Dilfer was much better than Manning.
goose
2/8/16 8:37am
Which is great. I like Mannnig a lot. But he is a TERRIBLE QB.
Josef K
2/8/16 8:40am
lololololol
goose
2/8/16 8:46am
No longer tied with Favre on wins - yesterday was 200 for Peyton
BYUFam1
2/8/16 8:51am
Yep, that win put him as the all time wins leader
goose
2/8/16 8:54am
Top three QB of all time.
Josef K
2/8/16 9:00am
I get that, but he was hurt for most of the season, he knew his role and.....
goose
2/8/16 9:03am
That is a demonstrably false statement
workindev
2/8/16 8:33am
It is demonstrably true. Worst passer rating in the NFL. 9/17 TD/INT ratio.
Josef K
2/8/16 8:39am
Carson Palmer, Brian Hoyer, and AJ McCarron all had worse post season QB ratings
workindev
2/8/16 8:43am
Okay. If you want to discuss this post season: 9.9 post season QBR. WORST EVER.
Josef K
2/8/16 9:04am
Meh, it happened to one of the all time greatest. He knew his place and his role
goose
2/8/16 8:33am
The ole ball scratch / handshake on your sig gif
workindev
2/8/16 8:47am
He actually didn't play like crap. He couldn't convert in the red zone, and
IndependentGeorge
2/8/16 8:55am
Why is it mocking to say he played poorly? Are you related?
SouthernBlueBlood
2/8/16 8:23am
Yes
Bravescoug
2/8/16 8:30am
Apparently because he's white
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:26am
What?
scootsy
2/8/16 8:33am
Oh, right . . . whites can't use the race card. My bad.
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:35am
I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. Regardless, why should whites be allowed to use the race card?
scootsy
2/8/16 8:50am
White isn't a race??????
ByuMba90
2/8/16 8:57am
Pay them no mind. They don't understand why it's cool
Cochise Cat
2/8/16 8:26am
did Newton play worse?
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:26am
Much
Bravescoug
2/8/16 8:29am
Higher QBR, more yards passing, despite playing against a better defense.
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:30am
Didn't attempt to recover a fumble that was his for the taking when
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:34am
so you're saying he made mistakes and didn't play well. pretty sure that
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:35am
You're saying game losing "mistakes" are not part of the "play well" equation?
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:43am
again, did I say Newton played well?
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:44am
You suggested he played better than the winning QB based on stats
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:47am
I didn't say he played better. I listed some reasons one could argue
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:49am
He also had more turnovers, and was completely incapable of scoring points
workindev
2/8/16 8:35am
is somebody saying he played well? wow. reading comprehension isn't
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:36am
Uh, you did
workindev
2/8/16 8:44am
I guess I'm not seeing the part where I said he played well.
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:50am
More yards passing because Carolina had to pass, Denver called a conservative
gilbertatty
2/8/16 8:36am
again, that wasn't the argument. Bravescoug said Newton played worse and
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:38am
Lack of heart = playing worse. You seem to be the one with comprehension fail
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:39am
how does one measure heart? I'd say he played with plenty of "heart"
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:41am
If you feel that refusing to dive on a fumble right in front of him = "heart"
LV Mike
2/8/16 8:44am
Manning led offense = 17 points, Newton led offense = 10 points
workindev
2/8/16 8:45am
so turnovers by teammates, dropped passes, etc, aren't part of the
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:47am
Huh? Newton was directly responsible for 3 of the 4 Carolina turnovers
workindev
2/8/16 9:01am
Mrs. Newton, Cam did not play well enough to win. He is young and may make it
BYUinTX
2/8/16 9:11am
He did? Don't think so. Manning did next to nothing. He didn't turn it over
Singcat
2/8/16 8:36am
yep. both QBs played really bad. to say one clearly outplayed the other is funny
smokymountainrain
2/8/16 8:39am
I never said hey won because of Manning. I never even said he played well. I
Bravescoug
2/8/16 10:42am
13 of 23 for Manning. 18 of 41 for Newton.
Cochise Cat
2/8/16 11:49am
He turned over twice. Once on a terrible interception and the other was a fumble
Josef K
2/8/16 4:50pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad